Reflections on Dr. Pretlow’s Webinar

Seafair Indian Days

This new webinar is called “The Epidemic of Childhood Obesity: What’s Our Plan?” and although Dr. Pretlow designed it for health care professionals, it’s probably safe to say that most parents feel they are included in that group — they have certainly put in the time!

The webinar covers two major questions. How do we spot childhood obesity, and then, what do we do about it? The purported causes of the obesity epidemic are examined, and treatment options are discussed. Since the obesity epidemic is so interrelated with public financing and public institutions, there are always policy considerations. What might we expect the government to do?

In the “causes” department, Dr. Pretlow talks about the food-rich environment. If it’s around, people will eat it. At first, this seems like an obvious, “no-brainer” explanation. But does not see it as enough of a reason.

Yes, the presence of a lot of food is a necessary condition to overeating, because before any person or group of people can overeat, food has to be there. But it’s not what the old-school philosophers would call a sufficient condition. The presence of massive amounts of hyperpalatable food is not, in itself, a guarantee that a person will make bad nutritional choices, or eat too much. This is demonstrated by the fact that plenty of people don’t make bad choices, or overeat, despite the abundance of available food.

Too expensive?

There is a popular belief that healthful food is expensive and boutiquey, and too costly for the ordinary working person to afford. But what about the Native American communities where casinos have brought in unprecedented wealth, but not much improvement in good nutritional choices? The popularity of “fry bread” is undiminished, as Dr. Pretlow can attest from many shared meals near his home base of Seattle.

Despite their ability to shop for whatever they choose, humans have a tendency to stick with dishes that have traditional ethnic and cultural significance. And sometimes, with crummy junk food diets.

Aside from the wealthy and unenlightened, another group draws criticism for preferring junk food and fast food — the very poor. Cooking from scratch is something not everyone can do. It takes a working stove and refrigerator, a paid-up electric bill, some equipment, a minimal store of condiments, and so on. Without a freezer, even a responsible adult inclined to shop at the farmers’ market can’t preserve organic fruits and vegetables beyond season.

A homeless person might seem to have the ideal opportunity to go with an all-raw vegan diet and become spectacularly healthy. But for someone living in the streets, it’s difficult enough to even find clean drinking water, much less water for fancy stuff like washing veggies. To carry around a knife for peeling apples and carrots could lead to a jail sentence.

People who are homeless, or signed up for various food assistance programs, don’t have much choice about what they eat. The shelter or soup kitchen serves what it serves. Donations to food pantries must necessarily be non-perishable foods, meaning they are filled with preservatives and pretty much drained of nutritional value.

People face all kinds of problems and obstacles that can’t really be understood by others who have not participated in the same lifestyle. Unavoidably, there is a certain amount of truth in the “good food is too expensive” argument. But it’s certainly not enough to explain the entire obesity epidemic.

And neither is the “food desert” theory, which posits that in some geographical areas and urban neighborhoods, people are both undernourished and obese because good food is not available. Yes, it is true that there are such places. That unfortunate fact is contributory to the obesity epidemic. But as a major causative factor, it doesn’t hold up. Dr. Pretlow says:

The kids that I have contact with say ‘No.’ They say where they are, there is some healthy food available, but nobody wants to buy it. So it appears that the residents of those communities just don’t want to buy healthy food, for whatever reason.

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “What’s Really Behind the Childhood Obesity Epidemic?,” Weigh2Rock.com
Image by Joe Mabel.

Leave a Reply

Childhood Obesity News | OVERWEIGHT: What Kids Say | Dr. Robert A. Pretlow
Copyright © 2014 eHealth International. All Rights Reserved.