A Trap to Vigorously Avoid

Seen on a neighbor’s wall, a poster stating, “What happens at Grandma’s house never happened.” Numerous possibilities present themselves. And if one word was changed — for instance, “What happened at Grandpa’s house never happened” — the imagination could go dark, but that is not our topic. The problem here, though not subject to legal prosecution, is nevertheless responsible for plenty of damage.

In the sort of ongoing warfare that can all too often occur in the home, a favored tactic is abuse based on personal characteristics, of which obesity is a temptingly obvious weapon — and a versatile one. If the parent is lucky enough to be of normal weight, a child can be emotionally abused for being obese.

Conversely, if the parent is obese, resentment can be directed toward a child who seems to have escaped that fate. The versatility is extended by the possibility of any generation pointing the weapon at either the elders or the youngsters.

In assessing whether a child might need some sort of therapy, it behooves a parent to consider whether he/she himself/herself might also benefit from therapy. After all, how did the kid get so messed up in the first place? Common sense says to look at the mother and/or the father, and if you happen to be either of those, go ahead and draw the obvious conclusion. It’s just possible that you could benefit from some inner work, too.

Relentless persistence

Otherwise, without psychological and emotional help, when the same resentful people become grandparents, the sick drama persists through another generation, to potentially be handed on to yet another generation after that, and so on, ad infinitum.

One thing we are talking about here is the everlasting variety of stuff that grandparents have been known to do, out of some obscure sense of ancient leftover spite that was churned up during the daughter’s or the son’s childhood, with residual bad feeling that winds up being inflicted on an innocent child.

Regarding the illustration at the top of the page, please refer to the traditional tale, “Little Red Riding Hood,” in which an alleged grandma is actually a vicious predator in disguise. Nobody wants that, yet some of us have experienced the phenomenon firsthand, as either victim, perpetrator, or both. Yes, this is the sort of dynamic that tends to repeat itself in families, tainting the emotional lives of one generation after another.

Alluring possibilities

Folks really need to look at the family dynamics that they have managed to ignore or tolerate. But when it comes to the kids, look out. On hearing the happy news that a daughter or daughter-in-law is expecting, something regrettable can happen in the brains of even the nicest women.

All bets are off, and specialized weapons have been lying in metaphorical closets for years, gathering dust, but ready to be spiffed up and called into use — start the countdown — four months from now… two months from now… The kid pops out, and soon, the mom and the grandma will need to navigate a whole new dynamic between them, and no matter what the relationship has previously been, there will be some surprises.

Neither party might even be conscious of the sense that there are scores to be settled. But that’s the tricky thing about feelings. They rarely rise to the level of consciousness. In the most outwardly cordial relationship between relatives, just below the surface might be an emotional jungle full of ravening beasts.

Beware of the urge to settle old scores

Buying too many gifts, exposing kids to radical ideas or alternate religious viewpoints, letting them stay up too late, allowing them to view inappropriate or undesirable TV programming, feeding them bowls of icing, taking them to unhealthy environments… There are a thousand ways to punish daughters and sons for past offenses by trifling with the rules and standards those offspring have drawn up for their own children. For a member of the older generation to declare, “That kid needs boundaries,” or to go in the opposite direction, “She’s not fat, just cuddly,” are both bad if motivated by ancient scripts that have been lurking around, just waiting for a chance to jump into the picture.

There are many ways to allegedly spoil a child — some of them more damaging than others. What is being suggested here is for each adult, whether parent, grandparent, step-parent, or babysitter, to carefully examine their own motives and self-deceptions about what the heck is actually going on.

“What do you call yourself doing?” is a countrified way to say, “What do you think you’re doing?” and in either form, or expressed in any other way, it is a valid question that people really do not ask themselves often enough.

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Image by Grafixxkoeln/Pexels

The B-word and the S-word

Blaming and shaming take many forms and have many faces. Back when Twitter existed, plenty of pseudonymous Americans exercised their right of free speech by stating that, because most pandemic fatalities occurred among folks with pre-existing medical conditions, the rest of us need not worry about dying of COVID.

Often, obesity was named as a liability, as well as other conditions associated with obesity. In many cases, it seemed that the opinionated citizens really wanted to say, “If they died from a little virus that a lot of people don’t even catch, it’s their own darn fault for being fat.”

“Othering” people, or presenting alleged evidence that sickness and death are the others’ own fault, apparently helps some folks nurture the fiction that they themselves could never possibly become a pandemic statistic.

A writer went so far as to proclaim that, in 90% of COVID fatalities, the actual cause of death was “selfish lifestyle choices,” which would, of course, include the choice to be overweight. Others retaliated by accusing the blamers of kidding themselves about that, just to preserve the comfortable fiction that it could never happen to them.

Righteous rhetoric is not universal

Of course, there are always other voices to offer other views. One example is an article titled “Harms of Framing Obesity as a Disease of Individuals,” which appeared last month in JAMA Health Forum:

[T]he currently dominant “obesity is a disease requiring individual treatment” framing undermines public and political support for tackling the epidemic’s root causes. First, we contend that the media-saturated debate centering medical treatments such as expensive glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) receptor agonists reinforces food, pharmaceutical, and wellness industry communication strategies emphasizing obesity as a problem requiring medical treatment, rather than prevention.

The authors said a mouthful, all right! But there is more:

Second, this framing focuses on individuals rather than the food environments individuals find themselves in, which are shaped by government-set laws and financial incentives for the food industry.

And, they offer a solution: Follow the example of the war on smoking, which has achieved at least partial success by simply pricing a lot of would-be tobacco fiends right out of the market. A skeptic could retort that we would then face the ludicrous sight of cars with tinted windows pulling up next to schools to peddle candy and cupcakes to innocent children.

But as it has done in so many similar cases, the government could probably arrange to discourage any sugar black market. Before our readers go on to read that very interesting article, let us contemplate just one more quotation from it:

Narratives describing an identified individual’s struggle with obesity […] generate less support for obesity prevention policies than depersonalized narratives” and “personalized stories make people less likely to […] support governmental actions.

Among the small percentage of adult Americans who could be considered healthy, a devout belief in the virtues of diet and exercise apparently helped to allay their fears. Of course, some of the same zealots had previously devoted their energy to dissing First Lady Michelle Obama, who did her best to encourage everyone to be as healthy as possible. Some critics are just never satisfied.

And, of course, there exists the possibility that both public and private action can coexist and support each other!

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “Harms of Framing Obesity as a Disease of Individuals,” JAMA Health Forum, 05/01/26
Image by truthseeker08/Pixabay

Adults, It’s On Us

As this blog has suggested before, there is a difference between feeling generous concern for the health of an obese person and being an ill-intentioned busybody.

As much as we wish that a certain relative would lose a few dozen pounds, this does not necessarily have to be said out loud — not to that person, or to third parties, or even to ourselves. Maybe our need to criticize people should be quashed as vigorously as their need to consume cheese crackers. It is incumbent upon us as grown-ups to restrain our own worst impulses.

Also, where children are concerned, adults really ought to acknowledge our own culpability in the whole childhood obesity quandary. Let’s face it. If a bunch of children were left alone in an island society free of grown-up mistakes, where there was just enough to eat, they wouldn’t get fat. If the opportunity to gobble down a bunch of junk did not exist, it simply would not happen. To be blunt, without the participation of grown-ups, children would not have the means or the opportunity to gain inappropriate amounts of weight.

What could help?

It’s a safe bet that every last person who ever expressed an opinion about someone else’s body has something less than perfect about their own body. In life, some things are just guaran-dang-teed, and one of them is that nobody is perfect. Couldn’t we just hush up about it and move on? Unless, of course, we are health professionals, but that is a topic for another day.

In society at large, would it help to more seriously study people who have somehow turned their lives around? How does a decision like that get made, anyway? What or who helped the person change their life? What were the aims and ambitions behind it? What finally changed their lives, and can we gain from that knowledge a sense of what might help children not be obese?

Story time

An anonymous reader tells about a childhood that included frequent visits to her maternal grandmother’s house, where she was allowed to make “icing,” otherwise known as a bowl of powdery confectioners’ sugar, moistened with water and consumed with a spoon. She writes:

One time when Mom came to pick me up, the bowl and the spoon were still in the kitchen sink, and the sugar hit the fan. Me turning into a pimply pile of blubber wasn’t even the issue. It was that Grandma had the nerve to make a decision like that. Mom did a lot of messed-up things, but she was the mom. At the time I was pretty upset, especially because Grandma didn’t stop feeding me that mess. So in addition to scarfing down liquified sugar, I was lying too. Eventually Mom found a neighbor close to home, and didn’t ask Grandma to babysit me any more.

Then she added,

Who knows, maybe that’s what Grandma was aiming for all along. I mean, it wasn’t a hundred years ago. Surely, tin cans were invented. She could have kept some canned peaches or something on hand instead, and fed me that. Just to show some pretense of awareness. Even if it had the same amount of calories as a bowl of sugar, it would have avoided trouble.

Peeks into other lives

In childhood, visiting a friend’s home can be an unsettling experience. Many of us grew up marveling at the items other kids sometimes brought to school in their lunchboxes, and all of a sudden, there we were, right in the heart of weirdness. It probably smelled funny, and you never knew what you would find.

Maybe anybody was allowed to raid the refrigerator at any time. Or maybe there was a locked cabinet above it. Did the big sister have an eating problem so serious that the parents had to keep her out of the cupcake stash? Or is that just where they stored the schnapps?

This should go without saying, but it would really behoove us, as grown-ups, to zip our lips and refrain from disparaging anyone — old or young, fat or thin, etc. It 99% won’t help, and might hurt. There isn’t a chance in Hades that any good will be done, any improvement attempted, or anybody going to sleep happier than they woke up.

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Image by cagdesign/Pixabay

Nice Try, Obesogenic Chemicals

As the old saying goes, “No news is good news.” It is a joking-but-not-really expression. If nobody came rushing up to you today saying, “Did you hear about… (some horrible thing),” then today was a good day. Since yesterday, no disaster has happened, and to be aware of that is, in its way, “good news.”

But lately, the expression “No news is good news” has taken on a whole different meaning. It’s pretty much all bad news. None of it could be classified as good. At least that’s how it looks on some days, doesn’t it?

Just to illustrate the point, here is a very recent headline, along with its subtitle:

“Dangerous hormone-disrupting chemicals found in US breast milk samples”
Study of mothers in Seattle underscores ‘widespread, systemic problem’ of chemical contamination, experts say

The journalist is Tom Perkins, who goes on to clarify: “Breast milk samples from mothers in Seattle contain alarming levels of dangerous hormone-disrupting chemicals.” Amongst those substances are BPA, BPS, and melamine, all of which perform the useful service of allowing food products to slide unhindered from their packaging materials.

BPA is associated with obesity, and so is BPS. Between them, they have a lot to do with an estimated 100 million (probably a lot more) cases of obesity worldwide. Apparently, the detection of melamine in breast milk is a fairly recent occurrence, but never fear, it is unlikely to disappear. In fact, Perkins reports, “Congress is considering gutting the nation’s laws around toxic chemicals.”

Further information is added by Ryan Babadi, senior scientist at a nonprofit called Toxic Free Future and a lead author of the pertinent study. He also affirms that this gunk being found in mothers’ milk represents a “widespread, systemic problem” for which we need “stronger protections […] not rollbacks.” His work explains what nobody in a civilized world should have to explain; namely, why and how the stuff makes its way into the mouths of infants “who are undergoing rapid stages of development that are orchestrated by the endocrine system.”

It’s not brand new

Previous studies have found endocrine disruptors, like, for instance, flame retardants, in mothers’ milk, which indicates trouble not only for those mothers and their children, but for the entire societal structure of “adults, workers, and communities.” This currently discussed study is one of the recent ones in which melamine is showing up for the first time.

Out of 50 specimens of mothers’ milk tested in this study, about 92% of them contained one or more of the substances the technicians were looking for, which are known to be “harmful at very low levels of exposure” — especially to a fetus, a possibility that should not even be conceivable outside the script of a horror movie. The news is all bad, because…

The chemicals have been found in epidemiological studies to have a wide range of developmental and reproductive harms.

How could those mothers let this happen? What were they thinking? And yet, we are assured that many of the study participants were intelligent, educated women, some of them even able to afford the highest quality groceries. In their defense, Babadi notes that the harmful chemicals are so universally present in edible products that the very concept of trying to avoid them is a joke. Consumers can’t just “shop their way out of this.”

The study also found cyanuric acid and triclosan, but they are old news at this point. Along with the breastfeeding hazard, these substances and others equally bizarre are found in commercially available baby formulas.

The Perkins piece leaves us with a thought that, after all this, is not actually very inspiring:

Babadi emphasized that breastfeeding remains the healthiest choice for infants when possible, because it is the most nutritious and generally the safest option.

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “Dangerous hormone-disrupting chemicals found in US breast milk samples,” TheGuardian.com, 06/14/26
Source: “BPA Exposure Linked to 127 Million Global Metabolic Disease Cases,” AJMC.com, 11/20/25
Image by K3IST/Pixabay

Blame and Shame — The Costs Mount Up

The recent post “It’s Worse Than Wrong, It’s Useless” points out a very high societal cost that occurs because of fat-shaming. The negative effect is to make lots of people feel bad about themselves, and/or about any overweight relatives and friends they happen to have. When we view the big picture, it is clear that any tendency to mentally divide the community into healthy-weight “good guys” and obese “bad guys” can lead to nothing but a bad end.

Of course, children and teens are not the only ones who experience fat-shaming. Grownups get plenty of it too, and the fact that most of it is probably done inadvertently and without awareness does not make the situation any better. In fact, subtlety is almost worse, in a way, because the target then wastes a lot of mental energy on analyzing whether the insult was intended or is merely a thoughtless incident.

When you stop and think about it, to state an opinion about anyone’s overweight condition is quite unfair, considering that the speaker might have some harmful tendency equally as serious, or even more so, that just doesn’t happen to show. Fat people are pathetically obvious targets, while individuals with far darker and more dangerous lifestyles may stroll among us looking innocent as lambkins. Why don’t we all just keep our thoughts to ourselves? As Grandma once embroidered on a sampler, “If you can’t say something nice, don’t say anything at all.”

Going to extremes

In a work that won’t even be footnoted here because, really, the whole thing is just gross and jam-packed with what is considered in polite society to be censorable language. George Carlin called obese people “huge piles of redundant protoplasm” and much, much worse. This subject, incidentally, only came up because of the random sighting of a meme making the claim that Carlin once said, “If you can’t fat-shame the one you love, fat-shame the one you’re with.” But verification of the remark proved elusive.

However, the takeaway provided by that quest is that if a graduate student ever wants to research the most extreme verbal abuse ever aimed at obese people, Carlin is the go-to source.

Next up

Now we look at a very personal essay by a writer known as Soler Bean, who has some things to say to anyone whose hobby is “trying to gauge someone’s health simply based on what they look like.” This does not mean the person is a particularly acute observer, but it might mean that she or he is a type of individual defined by a generic term that begins with the letter “a.” (Similar to George Carlin but on the opposite side of the debate, other folks become inspired to use rude language, too.)

One topic of discussion here is the plus-size performer Lizzo, who made a public appearance in a very small bathing suit. Condemning the star for “mindless glorification” of fat, a critic snarked, “Hopefully people with open wounds, leprosy or other diseases won’t start wearing tiny red bikinis.”

Leprosy? Seriously? But this is only one more example of how fat-shaming, body-shaming, and the pretense of caring about a large person’s well-being are rooted in our culture. Even the medical profession has been accused of automatically and erroneously equating thinness to health, wrongfully convicting fatness as the cause of illnesses that have nothing to do with weight.

The author deplores this holier-than-thou approach and gives examples of its effects on actual friends and acquaintances, and also provides a convenient list of points to remember:

1. People do not have to appear to be “healthy” for you to respect them.
2. Body shaming solves literally nothing.
3. Thinking that any food-related health issue can be entirely blamed on the individual and not the society around them is asinine.
4. Empathy goes a long way.
5. It costs $0.00 to mind your business.

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “The Reason You Hate Fat People Isn’t Because You Care About Their Health,” AnInjusticeMag.com, 02/09/20
Image by artist ID not given/Pixabay

It’s Worse Than Wrong, It’s Useless

The previous post touched on a couple of aspects of obesity, whether found in a child or an adult. The minute this subject comes up, it obviously raises some questions, such as: Why do many allegedly civilized adults feel it is their responsibility to notify overweight people about how much they disapprove? Granted, this treatment, when meted out to adults, and by adults, is much more subtle than the techniques employed by mean children. But it’s there, nonetheless.

Dr. Pretlow once pointed out that, according to research done by UC San Diego and apparently bumped offline since then, a group of young people undergoing chemotherapy against cancer, and another group of young people who were obese, rated their quality of life as pretty much the same.

A certain degree of puzzlement elicited a follow-up question: “If obese young people are truly miserable, due to being obese, why don’t they simply eat healthy, exercise, lose weight, and not be miserable anymore? Obviously, something else is going on.” That mysterious factor may simply (but, aha, not really so simply) be that they can’t stop using food as a tool in a transparently illogical coping mechanism. Deciding to eat less is quite a different matter from, for instance, deciding not to have cancer.

Hmmm…

Looking at this objectively, it seems possible that people, including the young, may have adopted for their own comfort the idea that all obesity is the fault of food manufacturers who fill their products with fattening ingredients, transforming them into “problem foods.” Which of course is valid to a certain extent — but nowhere near an extent that would justify all the overweight people using it as an excuse, all the time.

To make a long story short, it seems pretty obvious that, as Dr. Pretlow noted,

[…] rather than incriminating specific constituents of food as the cause of obesity, we should look at why people consume large amounts in the first place, and keep doing so, even though they are aware that it will result in further weight gain.

At any rate, either way, it is glaringly obvious that many overweight and obese people of all ages have a pretty hard time of it, just maintaining enough morale to support a bearable existence. Tempting as it is to shame and blame them, any improvement in the overall situation is liable to be quite negligible. Worsening of the overall situation, on the other hand, is a quite likely result.

A while back, radio personality Ira Glass of “This American Life” chose writer Lindy West as an interview subject. West is far from slender, and they discussed related topics, including self-esteem, quality of life, and fat-shaming. Glass reported that because West is married to a tall, handsome man, people meeting them socially will assume that they are not a couple.

Even if they’re at a bar holding hands, looking exactly like a couple, people say stuff to them like, so you guys roommates? Women hit on him in front of Lindy. She describes being fat as simultaneously being way too visible and being invisible — not wanting people looking at her, noticing her, noticing what she eats. She worried — and she worries still, all the time — about destroying chairs by sitting on them.

Glass went on to relate some of West’s remarks about hypocritical critics:

It’s not about health. It’s about “ew.” You think fat people are icky. Ew. A fat person might touch you on a plane with their fat. Ew! If you were concerned about my health, you would also be concerned about my mental health, which has spent the past 28 years being slowly eroded.

To another reporter from another publication, West described being uncomfortable in public because so many male comics have made her life miserable:

If I go to a comedy club and I look around, I don’t know which of the dudes lining the wall told me that I was too fat to get raped.

To yet another journalist, who asked about “the cultural relationship between fatness and moral failure,” she replied,

I still bought into the idea that I was broken and needed to be fixed. And that this was going to be the defining struggle of my life. That some day I would win, you know, I would defeat my body and I would become thin…

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “Tell Me I’m Fat,” ThisAmericanLife.org, 06/17/16
Source: “How to Fight Fat Shaming, Internet Trolls, and Rape Culture,” MotherJones.com, 05/23/16
Source: “Lindy West is the troll-fighting feminist warrior you’ve been waiting for,” LATimes.com, 05/20/16
Image by Kyra Starr/Pixabay

A Seminar, and So Much More

The source document here is a podcast transcript that combines the best features of two genres. The official title is “Fatness and the Body – Episode 2: Being fat or having obesity: combining social constructivism and biomedical research on childhood obesity.” On the other hand, much of the content is less like a scientific paper and more like talking with an erudite friend, in the quietest corner of a Saturday night house party.

The scholarly content comes from Adam Mickiewicz University, a research center which, under various administrations and with a few name changes, has existed in Poznan, Poland, since 1611. This episode is part of a larger program, Unit for Biocultural Variation and Obesity. Author Zofia Boni is absolutely tireless in her pursuit of both usable facts and of ways to present them to the concerned public.

It’s multifactorial

Her academic career has emphasized anthropology, socialist studies, feminist scholarship, epidemiology, climate science, demography, and other areas of interest, all to capture the big picture regarding childhood obesity. She notes that for children and youth, typical BMI calculations are not used, but rather percentiles and databases correlated to the child’s sex…

[…] and either according to the WHO standards, you can end up with around 30% of 8 year olds in Poland having overweight and obesity, or if you end up using the standards which are the oldest ones, then it’s around 20%… And among those numbers, it is assumed that around 3 to 4% are children with obesity.

In other words, “overweight” and “obesity” are shifty characters who refuse to stand still and have their pictures taken for the record. Boni recommends a viewpoint outside the North America-centric one, from which to gaze at the past decade or so from the perspective of a European graduate student asking questions about the distinction between obesity and fatness, which is always awkward terrain both methodologically and ethically. Furthermore, why does the distinction even matter, and not incidentally, who gets to decide?

Two faces

Boni, the excellent student, is comfortable seeking facts, precision, and certainty; while at the same time, it is almost as if someone else’s brain shares her skull:

So what I want to take from those perspectives in my own future research is on the one hand, recognizing that fatness is alright, so that people are thin and fat as they are small and tall, and not pathologizing or stigmatizing it, but then also recognizing that obesity has very troubling health consequences and physical and physiological consequences. And that there is such a disease as obesity. This is in a way connected I guess, but not every fat person has obesity, right?

Throughout years of research, the author has concentrated on two questions: How and why did obesity make the shift from being chiefly a personal problem, all the way to becoming a matter of public concern? And how do actual people, especially children, experience not only obesity, but the role of public enemy into which some factions of society often try to cast them?

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “Fatness and the Body’ Episode 2,” Podcasts.ox.ac.uk
Image by RaniRamli/Pixabay

Mutual Demolition Society

Seventy years ago, the American public loved a catchy tune whose lyric proclaimed, “We belong to a mutual admiration society.” The song celebrated a romantic relationship where each partner vied to outdo the other in proving their devotion.

Today, as Childhood Obesity News has mentioned more than once, our way of life embraces and encourages a “mutual demolition society,” where obesity and poverty tirelessly compete to see which one of them can do the most damage. Obesity leads to poverty, and as surely as night follows day, poverty leads to obesity, in a futile reciprocal see-saw effect that shows no sign of improving any time soon.

Ongoing folly

It has been argued for years that the medical profession and several government agencies waste a ton of resources in the service of a (mistaken) belief that gathering the Body Mass Index statistics of children is the ultimate road toward solving the childhood obesity problem. However, this view is not shared by all scientists in the field.

In 2014, Rodney Steadman wrote,

The BMI has become a big problem for some researchers… BMI does not accurately measure body fat in individuals with a high level of lean body mass (body weight minus the fat) and some ethnic groups. Furthermore, the BMI can be difficult to calculate in field settings when body weight cannot be accurately measured.

Meanwhile, parents who simply did not care for the whole idea argued with schools, and some challenged the ultimate usefulness of BMI information. As the Toronto Sun described in 2015, cultural and economic factors are involved:

[…] BMI information alone may not be enough to help parents in high poverty areas where fresh produce and safe playgrounds to encourage exercise may not be available.

Around the same time, a study found that BMI measurement failed to identify “as many as 25% of children, age 4 to 18 years, who have excess body fat.” The Mayo Clinic’s director of preventive cardiology, Francisco Lopez-Jimenez, said, “BMI is not capturing everybody who needs to be labeled as obese.”

And if they pass…

If someone is officially labeled obese, what then? That person now holds the credential of eligibility for bariatric surgery.

Leaving all other factors aside for the sake of discussion, it is possible to question the benefit of bariatric surgery overall. It cannot be considered a societal good to have a large proportion of society’s members absorbed by the overwhelmingly intense preparation agenda for an operation like this.

In contrast to even a limited public existence, the mundane routine of a person gearing up for, or recovering from, this type of procedure is not easy. For practical purposes, like holding down a job, the patient may be quite unable to conduct anything like a normal life.

However much of a blessing it may be in a particular case, in the long run, for that person, bariatric surgery is a very life-consuming project in terms of burning up time, energy, goodwill, money, and other resources.

Then, after the actual procedure, there is a similarly unproductive spell, as the patient is, to a greater or lesser degree, disabled for a considerable period of time. Even barring any unexpected side effects, there are new routines to learn and new norms to become accustomed to, on every side.

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “Teresa Brewer ‘Mutual Admiration Society’ on The Ed Sullivan Show,” YouTube.com, undated
Source: “Absurd, but True,” WordPress.com, 07/15/14
Source: “Screening teens for obesity may not help them lose weight,” TorontoSun.com, 07/03/15
Image by geralt/Pixabay

More on Additives and Advertising

Weird stuff inside the food, and enticing, persuasive words about the food: Both in their own distinctive ways are responsible for the overwhelming wave of obesity that has engulfed society.

Actually, nowadays, words are pretty superfluous, except to identify where to get the stuff. People who sell just about anything tend to rely mainly on pictures to do the convincing for them. Matters in that realm are definitely advancing. Still, in certain situations, like in cars where they are not supposed to have their attention fixed on screens, people are still quite able to be influenced by words alone.

When it comes to pouring enormous amounts of money into the economy, visual and auditory stimuli both play their parts. Every little purchase of a convenience-store doughnut, glimpsed by someone who just went in there to pay for gas, performs its role in the overall ascendency of food.

Or maybe automotive fuel has nothing to do with it. Maybe somebody pulled off the highway after listening to a radio advertisement for McDonald’s. Even if this isn’t Mickey D’s place, the ad has elicited hunger pangs in the driver, who is not taking any chances on the odds of spotting yellow arches any time soon. He or she will happily chow down on whatever they can get right now.

Children grow up to be that driver, and that driver produces more children who will take after him or her. They become accustomed to hearing constant demands that they drop whatever they are doing, and lay their hands on something that can be quickly conveyed to their mouths. Like devout zombies, they hear and obey.

Two for the price of one

The bizarre chemicals added to food and the words said about food both play their parts to account for enormous expenditure by individual members of the public. Additionally, we pay even more via the government agencies and bureaus that exist to try to stem such evils as the damage caused by obesity.

All these financial demands could be alleviated by more widespread awareness and a stronger resolve on the part of the public to do something about them. There is no need to arm ourselves with pitchforks, like the townsfolk in an old-time monster movie. We are not asked to roam beneath a full moon to hunt down the entrepreneurs who make and peddle the chemicals, or the ad agency moguls who sell us sugar and bright colors and substances that could only with the most lavish addition of imagination be described as nourishing.

One way for members of the public to effectively react would be to band together, raise our voices, and demand that the government Do Something. Of course, as always, when the government is asked to, or assumes the right to, intervene in the sale of a product or service, differences of opinion may arise.

For instance, when any market commodity is in short supply, should the government allow another company to also sell it? For how long? But what if Company B offers it to customers at a lesser price than Company A, the one that invented the stuff and holds the patent on it? Should the government then intervene again, and put a stop to that seemingly unfair practice? After all, it was that first corporation that hired all the scientists and bought all the test tubes so the product could be deemed fit for consumption.

However, in the business world, “shortage” has more than one meaning. There may be a worldwide shortage of titanium, for instance, because mining companies can’t locate accessible deposits of it in the earth, or dig it up fast enough to meet the demand.

But — the ingredients of GLP-1 agonists are not as rare as titanium. In manufacturing those drugs, the unavailability of the raw materials is not a factor. Any company that can lay its hands on the raw materials can make some. They just can’t sell it unless the government says okay. However, critics believe that to prevent them from doing so — in order to give one pharmaceutical giant a monopoly — is wrong.

This is why Thomas L. Knapp wrote the accusatory article, “Semaglutide: Artificial Shortage is Novo Nordisk’s Business Model.” The fact that other companies — if allowed — can whip up a batch of the same potion any day of the week, and sell it at a fraction of Novo Nordisk’s price, looks like a conspiracy against the vast public who clamor for medication that helps them lose weight without losing the deed to the house, their kids’ college funds, and great-grandma’s wedding ring.

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “Semaglutide: Artificial Shortage is Novo Nordisk’s Business Model,” TheGarrisonCenter.org, 02/10/26
Image by kaboompics/Pixabay

Another Junky Year

To look back a year into U.S. history does not promote a warm, fuzzy feeling of nostalgia, but rather something closer to revulsion. Toward the end of May in 2025, New York Times reporters Sheryl Gay Stolberg and Dani Blum told readers that a recent presidential commission had just painted a “bleak picture of American children.”

They discussed what the government was saying, doing, and not doing, about a list of conditions and circumstances affecting childhood obesity — like ultra-processed foods; stress; insufficient exercise; drugs, including antidepressants; and exposure to chemicals that either are or should be avoidable to varying degrees.

Perhaps unwilling to recall the tremendous effort that former First Lady Michelle Obama had exerted to bring awareness to the problem, the 68-page commission mentioned the word “obesity” only three times, although it divulged the information that 40% of Americans were obese. Also, Americans were getting pretty much half their calories from ultraprocessed foods (UPFs). This is a real head-scratcher, and maybe above our pay grade, but… could there possibly be a connection?

Regardez-vous les autres…

Meanwhile, compare three European countries — France, Italy, and Portugal — where the citizens obtain only between 10% and 30% of their calories from UPFs. Reader, prepare for a shock: only fewer than one-quarter of those folks qualify as obese.

Anyway, about a year ago, a presidential commission led by Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. issued a report that included the phrase, “the sickest generation in American history.” The officials who were expected to identify the reasons for that found plenty. A case was made that this country’s medical research establishment has been placing too much emphasis on eradicating specific diseases.

Historically, in many cases, that has been proven possible, yet somehow a feeling seems to exist that more energy should be expended on treating illnesses and identifying their causes, rather than trying to eliminate them from the biosphere altogether. Why there should be any controversy over this point is difficult to understand. We are America. Why not boldly aspire to do it all?

Do corporations exert too much influence on policy?

Probably, folks of any political persuasion would agree that corporations are too powerful in this aspect of life, differing only in their assessment of which corporations have too much influence, and of what sort, and what ought to be done about it.

In fact, upon first hearing, most generalizations sound pretty much the same. Two people might agree that American children are over-medicalized, and at the same time operate from very divergent sets of assumptions and beliefs.

Anyone may read the entire MAHA report. It says unkind things about topics also discussed here at Childhood Obesity News, like the diets of American children, which are rife with such engineered substances as ultra-processed fats, grains, and sugars. This dreck makes up two-thirds of their total caloric intake.

The authors note that Mr. Kennedy is happy with neither America’s food system nor its plethora of environmental toxins. Various of his viewpoints are contrary to those favored by his supporters, while many of his thoughts also disagree, as might be expected, with other opinions and beliefs.

2,500

By a strange coincidence, the report issued in 2025 included a very similar figure — 2,500 — which happens to be the number of dicey, or at least questionable, additives found in what the kids are eating these days. The strange brews include “emulsifiers, binders, sweeteners, colorings, and preservatives” with names like Propylparaben, Butylated Hydroxytoluene, and Titanium Dioxide, which (whether honored with capital letters in their names or not — it seems to be optional) do not look or sound attractive.

According to the report,

Studies have linked certain food additives to increased risks of mental disorders, ADHD, cardiovascular disease, metabolic syndromes and even carcinogenic effects. Additionally, preliminary evidence suggests a possible association between the consumption of food colorings and autism…

Many substances also disrupt the gut microbiome, which increasingly appears as vitally important as the brain. It is possible that parents who worry about their kids sustaining brain damage through drug use might appropriately be just as concerned over potential gut microbiome devastation from some of those 2,500 food additives.

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “Kennedy and Trump Paint Bleak Picture of Chronic Disease in U.S. Children,” NYTimes.com, 05/22/25
Source: “The MAHA Report,” US-Gov-West-1, 2025
Image by Pat Hartman/Pixabay (Squirrel_photos, JohnHain)

FAQs and Media Requests: Click here…

Profiles: Kids Struggling with Weight

Profiles: Kids Struggling with Obesity top bottom

The Book

OVERWEIGHT: What Kids Say explores the obesity problem from the often-overlooked perspective of children struggling with being overweight.

About Dr. Robert A. Pretlow

Dr. Robert A. Pretlow is a pediatrician and childhood obesity specialist. He has been researching and spreading awareness on the childhood obesity epidemic in the US for more than a decade.
You can contact Dr. Pretlow at:

Presentations

Dr. Pretlow’s invited presentation at the American Society of Animal Science 2020 Conference
What’s Causing Obesity in Companion Animals and What Can We Do About It

Dr. Pretlow’s invited presentation at the World Obesity Federation 2019 Conference:
Food/Eating Addiction and the Displacement Mechanism

Dr. Pretlow’s Multi-Center Clinical Trial Kick-off Speech 2018:
Obesity: Tackling the Root Cause

Dr. Pretlow’s 2017 Workshop on
Treatment of Obesity Using the Addiction Model

Dr. Pretlow’s invited presentation for
TEC and UNC 2016

Dr. Pretlow’s invited presentation at the 2015 Obesity Summit in London, UK.

Dr. Pretlow’s invited keynote at the 2014 European Childhood Obesity Group Congress in Salzburg, Austria.

Dr. Pretlow’s presentation at the 2013 European Congress on Obesity in Liverpool, UK.

Dr. Pretlow’s presentation at the 2011 International Conference on Childhood Obesity in Lisbon, Portugal.

Dr. Pretlow’s presentation at the 2010 Uniting Against Childhood Obesity Conference in Houston, TX.

Food & Health Resources