Words, Feelings, and Healthcare Professionals

A few years ago, someone noticed that while research had been done to determine how overweight people felt about the names that friends, relatives, and strangers chose to call them, nobody had really looked at patients’ emotional response to the terminology used by healthcare professionals. To make this inquiry involved surveying almost 3,000 adults (2,911 actually), of whom well over half (1,963) were actually overweight or obese. Others were the parents of children with weight problems, and all were asked to express their opinions about the relevant vocabulary.
The researchers chose 22 common English words and phrases, and here they all are:
Overweight, obese, higher weight, weight problem, unhealthy weight, weight, heavy, chubby, fat, extremely obese, large, plus size, curvy, big, BMI, high BMI, morbidly obese, very overweight, extra large, obesity, super obese, excess weight.
As it turned out, the great majority of respondents found “weight” and “unhealthy weight” to be the least offensive terms. Many people preferred references to the BMI number, despite the fact that it has become much less respected as a meaningful standard.
The reported reactions are complicated:
The term “BMI” may be perceived positively and thus preferred by people within the healthy weight range, while people living with overweight or obesity may consider the term BMI to represent a perceived threat, and do not prefer its use. Further research is required to explore these differences in the preference based on the word “BMI”.
Grownups do not want themselves or their children to be described as super-obese, extremely obese, extra-large, or even fat. And chubby? Forget it. Nobody thinks that word is softer or less offensive than any of the others.
Hurt feelings
Respondents reported their emotional states when offensive terminology is used. Not surprisingly, the feelings inspired by various rejected terms included sadness, anger, disgust, contempt, and several other negative states. The researchers discovered that parents react differently to certain words used by healthcare professionals in relation to the grownups themselves, versus when describing their children. The report duly observed that “HCPs working with adults and children should note these subtle nuances.”
They also suggested that clothing manufacturers might get a clue and stop using some of their accustomed descriptors. Young customers particularly do not want to hear “extra-large,” nor do they care for “super obese” or even the seemingly inoffensive “chubby.”
Fine distinctions
The findings included some noteworthy details. For instance, the word “obese” by itself inspires sadness, while more descriptive adjectives added to it, like “extremely” and “morbidly,” stir up feelings of disgust.
The researchers found this interesting because in other studies, when normal-weight participants are asked what, exactly, it is about heavy people that they find so objectionable, they tend to use the word “disgust” a lot. They often report how that emotion is responsible for their negative emotions, including weight bias, negativity, and extreme prejudice. One captivating detail is described here:
Interestingly, evidence suggests that although some parents might be upset by HCPs using the words “overweight” or “obese”, these terms would be concerning enough to motivate them to make changes.
Many of the results suggested that there are still more layers of meaning to sort through before coming to any definitive conclusions. For instance, advice has been offered to use “person-first language,” for example “person living with obesity” — but that construction apparently does not reduce patients’ hostility toward the term “obesity” itself. The consensus is that professionals need to show more compassion, and the best available advice so far seems to be this:
HCPs should use “weight” when discussing body weight with both adults and children. Given that “weight” was the uniformly preferred term across all BMI categories, and elicited the least negative emotional response… HCPs are advised to use weight neutral terms and ask people for their preferred weight-related terms, as not all terms are uniformly accepted.
(Note to any reader who looks up the document discussed here: The authors consistently use the word “adverb” when they mean “adjective.” But they are not English majors. The scientific aspects of their material are presumed to have passed inspection by many knowledgeable eyes.)
Your responses and feedback are welcome!
Source: “Preferences and emotional response to weight-related terminology used by healthcare professionals to describe body weight in people living with overweight and obesity,” Wiley.com, 06/09/21
Image by rhuf/Pixabay









FAQs and Media Requests: