Chasing Stigma Through the Ages, Part 4

Author Erving Goffman has more to tell us about the inner lives of people who carry around too many pounds. Since one of these people could be a beloved child of yours or mine, it just might be useful to check out Goffman’s insights about this matter, especially the parts that involve interactions with strangers.

In recent years, out there in the world, a lot of attention has been focused on one particular way in which a child can be damaged. Sadly, that is not the only possible way. Although less immediately traumatic (and less punishable by law) than inappropriate contact, the focusing of negative attention on a child’s weight can cause significant harm.

A random stranger can do damage in a minute that will reverberate for years, causing emotional pain and influencing behavior. For instance,

The stigmatized individual can also attempt to correct his condition indirectly by devoting much private effort to the mastery of areas of activity ordinarily felt to be closed on incidental and physical grounds to one with his shortcoming.

A person who is unable to shed fat might adapt to it in a way that seems good-natured and healthy.  As parallel examples, Goffman mentions a wheelchair basketball team, or “the blind person who becomes expert at skiing and mountain climbing.” There is nothing wrong with such an adaptation, except that in the case of a dangerously overweight person, it might only signify avoidance which, if it could be overcome, would illustrate that the same amount of energy, differently applied, could actually have solved the obesity problem instead.

Multiple possibilities

Whether the physical fact is a facial scar, hilariously prominent ears, or obesity, some very odd psychological effects may ensue:

The stigmatized individual is likely to use his stigma for “secondary gains,” as an excuse for ill success that has come his way for other reasons… It is the “hook” on which the patient has hung all inadequacies, all dissatisfactions, all procrastinations and all unpleasant duties of social life…

Just as effectively as a facial scar, morbid obesity can be used as an excuse to avoid competitive situations and other types of challenges. It can be manipulated into a reason to ignore normal social responsibilities, or provide a plausible excuse for the person’s refusal to become emotionally involved. If a miracle comes along, like a way to pay for bariatric surgery, a whole new landscape of problems might open up.

In ways either recognized or unacknowledged, the severe medical handicap might have functioned as a screen that always served to hide some other problems:

He is unprepared to cope with this situation without the support of a “handicap,” and he may turn to the less simple, but similar, protection of the behavior patterns of neurasthenia, hysterical conversion, hypochondriasis or the acute anxiety states.

Strange as it may seem, to undergo successful weight-loss surgery, and follow it up with all the right moves, may not be the end of the story. The transformation might not even last very long. Some folks feel anxiety and/or depression. Objectively, the body might be lookin’ good, but the sad truth is that’s a stranger in the mirror. And the world might be just as full of strangers as it ever was.

It works both ways

Friends who enjoyed the company of one of those jolly fat people with the legendary sense of humor might now be confronted with an unfamiliar human who is anxious, depressed, confused, and bummed out because now, s/he no longer even has the coping mechanism of eating food for comfort. The formerly overweight person might not have realized there would be so much loose skin. The miraculous weight-loser might feel like s/he went to a whole lot of trouble and expense just to wind up feeling more alienated than before.

If alcohol use was not a problem previously, it might be now, because the body absorbs substances differently.  If the patient already had a lover or spouse, that partner might undergo unexpected emotional impact, and the whole relationship may have to be renegotiated. Children might feel uncomfortable with their greatly changed mom or dad. If the patient had been unattached, s/he might have expected to find someone quickly, and feel unjustly rejected. If suicide had never been “on the table” before, it might now look like a viable alternative.

What is going on here?

Why are we even bringing up such depressing scenarios?

As a way of reminding ourselves that going through life vulnerable to any sort of stigma can be a miserable existence. To remind ourselves that we certainly do not want to inflict any of this misery on our children, and that there are ways to avoid having obese children.

Not to be too obvious, but this is a good place for a reminder. If it seems that this sort of trouble might be brewing at home, it might be helpful to have a look at Brainweighve.

You’re welcome!

Source: “Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity,” WordPress.com, 1963
Images by Tumisu, trtasfiq/Pixabay

Chasing Stigma Through the Ages, Part 3

Here is the sort of fact that AI proves its singular brand of genius by identifying: In modern written English, the verb “stigmatize” occurs only once in every million words.

In real life, the act of stigmatizing occurs a million times every second. Yes, that is only a figure of speech, not officially verified. But an aware parent is all too likely to discover that when their kid is stigmatized, one incident per year is too many.

We don’t want a child to cry because another six-year-old decided that it’s lame to bring an apple in your home-packed lunchbox, and made an issue out of it. Nor do we want a 14-year-old to contemplate suicide because some teenage idiot mocked his haircut. Humiliating one’s peers is a favorite sport of kids, and learning how to avoid being targeted is an important life skill.

To stigmatize a fellow human being is to brand, label, mark, stamp, defame, denounce, and disgrace… All things that a decent parent does not want done to a daughter or son, no more than they would want that child to be shot, drowned, or set on fire. Acknowledging his expertise on the subject, we stick for a while longer with author Erving Goffman:

By definition, of course, we believe the person with a stigma is not quite human. On this assumption we exercise varieties of discrimination, through which we effectively, if often unthinkingly, reduce his life chances.

Tragically, even some parents exist who practice types of discrimination against their own overweight offspring, and effectively reduce those children’s odds of ever achieving various life benefits, including mental health. Those parents are of course welcome on this page, with the understanding that they need more help than can be found here, and with the hope that they recognize the sad fact and seek that help.

Sticks and stones may break my bones…

“[b]ut words will never hurt me.” For centuries, parents have repeated that old saying to their children, with little effect. Goffman, of course, mentions the obvious: the cruel propensity for inventing rude nouns and adjectives to characterize the stigmatized people. In our particular area of interest, we have seen how even the professionals who are trained and paid to care most about their clients have been capable of using, and even coining, terminology that can easily be read as offensive.

But of course, it goes further than verbal insults. Humans have always had a wonderful talent for explaining the world by constructing mythologies, origin stories, legends, doctrines, lore, and folk tales to explain the various universal phenomena of everyday life. Goffman wrote,

We construct a stigma-theory, an ideology to explain his inferiority and account for the danger he represents… We tend to impute a wide range of imperfections on the basis of the original one, and at the same time to impute some desirable but undesired attributes, often of a supernatural cast, such as “sixth sense,” or “understanding…”

That last remark is striking because, of course, it is true of fat people, who are rumored to be gifted with an extraordinary sense of humor. On the downside, however, this is countered by the large number of associated negative stereotypes that are so familiar, there is no need to list them here. Goffman wrote,

Shame becomes a central possibility, arising from the individual’s perception of one of his own attributes as being a defiling thing to possess, and one he can readily see himself as not possessing… In some cases it will be possible for him to make a direct attempt to correct what he sees as the objective basis of his failing.

Obesity is famous for being — unlike blindness, for instance — a handicap that a person can get rid of just by taking control and doing what’s necessary to shed 50 or 250 pounds. Many people have done exactly that, and still come out on the other side with problems.

Or, they were unable to succeed in the first place, often because of insufficient knowledge and preparation. The author cites “[…] the stigmatized person’s exposure to fraudulent servers selling speech correction, skin lighteners, body stretchers, youth restorers, cures through faith….” or, in this case, shady peddlers of methods and medicines that somehow just never seem to work out.

Here is Goffman’s take on one way in which “happily ever after” can be an elusive outcome:

Where such repair is possible, what often results is not the acquisition of fully normal status, but a transformation of self from someone with a particular blemish into someone with a record of having corrected a particular blemish.

Who wants to spend the rest of their life being introduced with the footnote, “You’re not gonna believe this, but Howard used to weigh more than 400 pounds!”

Of course, it’s still preferable to the alternative.

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “Stigmatize,” OED.com, undated
Source: “Stigmatize,” Thesaurus.com, undated
Source: “Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity,” WordPress.com, 1963
Image by diegartenprofis/Pixabay

Chasing Stigma Through the Ages, Part 2

“Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity” is a golden oldie, a work published years ago (more than 60 of them) that makes so many excellent points, the question arises: “What else about that subject could possibly have been thought or said since then?”

The author Erving Goffman seems to have pretty much said it all, with an enviable expertise in the art of seeing and articulating multiple aspects and angles of a topic — and the concept of stigmatization gave him plenty of raw material to work with.

The author noted that certain individuals and groups seem to possess an immunity to stigma. Whatever is thought or said about them, they simply don’t care. The Roma are an obvious example of people who have done their own thing for centuries, oblivious to the opinions of the world. Whether critics have admitted it or not, they have been unable to avoid feeling respect, right alongside the hate.

Inescapable truth

The ugly fact is that stigmatization carries many associations and can manifest in innumerable ways. One is the identifier, the outward sign. If nature neglected to provide the identifier (for instance, a different color of skin), humans have obligingly figured out how to supply the lack. In ancient society, law dictated that the good people should restrain a transgressor, and brand his or her face with an ineradicable mark, as a warning to the normies who deem themselves acceptable.

In practical terms, belonging to a certain race is something that cannot, in any case, be changed. This factor provides society with a group of people who can be looked down on, and treated differently. To separate and “other” those problematic folks, the righteous majority does not even need to take the trouble to heat up a branding iron. The stigma of shame does not need to be added. It arrives as part of the package.

Cruel nature

What happened when a child was born with a birthmark? Did the leader gasp and warn the rest of the people that such a mutant should immediately be smothered? The reactions of different societies to such challenges are the story of civilization, which in many places and over the course of millennia, seems not to have progressed much.

What happens now when a person shows up with purple hair? The range of tolerance can vary. When an individual goes so far out of their way to be so confoundingly different, some would want that rebel thrown in jail, for reasons they may not have examined. Others, astonished that anyone could feel so strongly about the issue, shrug and say “It’s no skin off my nose.”

When a person is different due to an accident of nature, Goffman reminds us,

Shame becomes a central possibility, arising from the individual’s perception of one of his own attributes as being a defiling thing to possess, and one he can readily see himself as not possessing.

Someone born with a facial birthmark, or a gigantic nose, or an allergy to sunlight, or a preference for same-sex partners, isn’t trying to make trouble. They didn’t do that on purpose. They didn’t ask to be different, and certainly never intended to make others uncomfortable or upset in their presence. And yet, a certain proportion of fellow humans will make it their business — nay, their mission — to be sure the divergent person feels uncomfortable and unacceptable.

A tricky exam

If asked to name the most powerful destructive force on earth, most people would probably answer, “a nuclear bomb,” while a certain proportion would say “shame.” Millions of people feel the pain of shame, mostly generated by factors they can’t control, like having been born with a facial birthmark. This is the secret door to understanding the phenomenon of fat-phobia, the condition that causes a human (who might be a perfect darling in every other way) to fear and/or hate humans who are overweight.

Even someone who might feel compassion for the person with a facial birthmark, or stretch their mind and heart far enough to understand that another person could not help being gay — even someone who is that far advanced will let themselves freely hate a morbidly obese person on the grounds that they didn’t have to be that way.

That person let themselves get fat, made themselves get fat, and does not care one single bit how uncomfortable the sight of their corpulent body makes others feel. Therefore, that person deserves to experience every bit of shame that can possibly be piled on them, from every direction, day and night, for the rest of their disgusting life.

This, Moms and Dads, is one of the very excellent reasons why we would rather not have our kids become overweight.

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity,” WordPress.com, 1963
Images by Conmongt and Tumisu/Pixabay

Chasing Stigma Through the Ages

Because some truths are eternal, today’s post refers to a work published six decades ago, whose roots go back centuries. Written by Erving Goffman, its title is “Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity,” and its subject is one that concerns us because if our children grow up to be unacceptably obese according to the standards of the time and place, stigma is what they will face daily throughout their lives.

The word itself has a complicated origin, intertwined with not only punitive laws but with the Christian religion. Stigmata are wounds or scars that spontaneously appear on the body of a saint or other particularly holy individual, in locations (hands, feet, torso) commemorating the violence inflicted on Jesus during the crucifixion.

But no…

What we are talking about here is the other meaning, the intentionally inflicted wounds that served as warning labels, signaling to others that they should avoid a stranger because of potential trouble. The presence of those scars meant, “To help this escaped slave could get you imprisoned,” or “While this sinner did not do something bad enough for a sentence of execution, he was convicted of a serious crime, so steer clear.” It’s where the expression “He’s a marked man” came from — there would be a literal mark, usually on the face, the meaning of which was clear to the general public.

One of the points made by Goffman’s work is that “shifts have occurred in the kinds of disgrace that arouse concern.” To be stigmatized, a person no longer needs to be a fugitive or a convict — or to be held down and branded with a hot iron. A body that is too big, according to the standards of the time and place, is enough to signify that a person’s “social identity” is one that decent, upstanding, right-minded citizens might (and probably should) be repelled by. Because of this expectation, it is easy to “read” the stranger as worthy of blame for being dangerous, evil, or at the very least, weak.

The author’s extensive study of the subject causes him to occasionally throw in a phrase like,

A stigma, then, is really a special kind of relationship between attribute and stereotype.

How does this relationship manifest itself, out in the world?

The term stigma and its synonyms conceal a double perspective: does the stigmatized individual assume his differentness is known about already or is evident on the spot, or does he assume it is neither known about by those present nor immediately perceivable by them?

Then, in many instances, another if/then factor becomes apparent. Even in the case of obvious differentness, like skin color or obesity — does anybody really care? If they don’t, then the interaction or the relationship can move on to more relevant points.

But just in case

In reaction to a stigmatized individual, the author points out, we let our prejudiced mental stereotypes take over — “transforming them into normative expectations, into righteously presented demands.” Those demands can show up in many guises. For instance, if the morbidly obese stranger is gracious enough to make a little joke like, “Gee, I hope I don’t break your chair,” we might feel inclined to give that person a pass (at least temporarily) because they have bowed to our automatic revulsion by acknowledging how disgusting they are.

Our mental filing cabinet registers that gesture of surrender and makes a note: “At least she knows her place in the hierarchy of worthiness.” The overweight individual can mollify and (temporarily, anyway) neutralize our disgust by confessing to their inadequacy. A fat teenager can become acceptable and even popular within a friend group by frequently insulting himself and saving everybody else the effort.

Acceptance, even grace

A stigmatized person who bows to, and often acknowledges, the group’s stereotypes can earn forgiveness. In their subconscious minds, the others are doing the person a favor by granting a temporary pass into the human race. Of course, the trouble with a temporary pass is that it can be revoked at any time.

We are only on Page 5, and Goffman is just getting started. Here are a few more points:

By definition, of course, we believe the person with a stigma is not quite human. On this assumption we exercise varieties of discrimination…

We construct a stigma-theory, an ideology to explain his inferiority and account for the danger he represents…

We use specific stigma terms…

We tend to impute a wide range of imperfections on the basis of the original one…

Obviously, even the most limited and un-intellectually inclined “normal” individuals can generate sufficient insults, pranks, slurs, putdowns, slights, taunts, and sneers to make anyone’s life miserable. But wait, there is more:

Further, we may perceive his defensive response to his situation as a direct expression of his defect, and then see both defect and response as just retribution for something he or his parents or his tribe did, and hence a justification of the way we treat him.

When persecutors with a few more brain cells, material resources, and additional free time become involved, they have the means to concoct entire theoretical constructs and mythologies and old wives’ tales to justify the mistreatment of some particular type of person. Not only that, but they can accrue enough power and influence to affect the scientific fundamentals, and even the religious institutions and the legal underpinnings of a society, to the detriment of a chosen group.

(To be continued…)

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity,” WordPress.com, 1963
Image by Tumisu/Pixabay

Words, Feelings, and Healthcare Professionals

A few years ago, someone noticed that while research had been done to determine how overweight people felt about the names that friends, relatives, and strangers chose to call them, nobody had really looked at patients’ emotional response to the terminology used by healthcare professionals. To make this inquiry involved surveying almost 3,000 adults (2,911 actually), of whom well over half (1,963) were actually overweight or obese. Others were the parents of children with weight problems, and all were asked to express their opinions about the relevant vocabulary.

The researchers chose 22 common English words and phrases, and here they all are:
Overweight, obese, higher weight, weight problem, unhealthy weight, weight, heavy, chubby, fat, extremely obese, large, plus size, curvy, big, BMI, high BMI, morbidly obese, very overweight, extra large, obesity, super obese, excess weight.

As it turned out, the great majority of respondents found “weight” and “unhealthy weight” to be the least offensive terms. Many people preferred references to the BMI number, despite the fact that it has become much less respected as a meaningful standard.

The reported reactions are complicated:

The term “BMI” may be perceived positively and thus preferred by people within the healthy weight range, while people living with overweight or obesity may consider the term BMI to represent a perceived threat, and do not prefer its use. Further research is required to explore these differences in the preference based on the word “BMI”.

Grownups do not want themselves or their children to be described as super-obese, extremely obese, extra-large, or even fat. And chubby? Forget it. Nobody thinks that word is softer or less offensive than any of the others.

Hurt feelings

Respondents reported their emotional states when offensive terminology is used. Not surprisingly, the feelings inspired by various rejected terms included sadness, anger, disgust, contempt, and several other negative states. The researchers discovered that parents react differently to certain words used by healthcare professionals in relation to the grownups themselves, versus when describing their children. The report duly observed that “HCPs working with adults and children should note these subtle nuances.”

They also suggested that clothing manufacturers might get a clue and stop using some of their accustomed descriptors. Young customers particularly do not want to hear “extra-large,” nor do they care for “super obese” or even the seemingly inoffensive “chubby.”

Fine distinctions

The findings included some noteworthy details. For instance, the word “obese” by itself inspires sadness, while more descriptive adjectives added to it, like “extremely” and “morbidly,” stir up feelings of disgust.

The researchers found this interesting because in other studies, when normal-weight participants are asked what, exactly, it is about heavy people that they find so objectionable, they tend to use the word “disgust” a lot. They often report how that emotion is responsible for their negative emotions, including weight bias, negativity, and extreme prejudice. One captivating detail is described here:

Interestingly, evidence suggests that although some parents might be upset by HCPs using the words “overweight” or “obese”, these terms would be concerning enough to motivate them to make changes.

Many of the results suggested that there are still more layers of meaning to sort through before coming to any definitive conclusions. For instance, advice has been offered to use “person-first language,” for example “person living with obesity” — but that construction apparently does not reduce patients’ hostility toward the term “obesity” itself. The consensus is that professionals need to show more compassion, and the best available advice so far seems to be this:

HCPs should use “weight” when discussing body weight with both adults and children. Given that “weight” was the uniformly preferred term across all BMI categories, and elicited the least negative emotional response… HCPs are advised to use weight neutral terms and ask people for their preferred weight-related terms, as not all terms are uniformly accepted.

(Note to any reader who looks up the document discussed here: The authors consistently use the word “adverb” when they mean “adjective.” But they are not English majors. The scientific aspects of their material are presumed to have passed inspection by many knowledgeable eyes.)

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “Preferences and emotional response to weight-related terminology used by healthcare professionals to describe body weight in people living with overweight and obesity,” Wiley.com, 06/09/21
Image by rhuf/Pixabay

Stigma and Association

Not long ago, an academic paper with several authors examined the existence and relationship of two concepts: weight stigma and weight stigma by association. The subjects were members of “a large, community-based sample.”

One objective was to rate parents on how caring and helpful they were willing to be, along with a rating to indicate how well they succeeded in that effort. When the results were tallied, it appeared that both obese parents and non-obese ones care equally for their children, be they daughters or sons. Furthermore, obese and non-obese parents are equally caring.

But: Obese parents are less effective, and parents of obese children are less effective.

One conclusion drawn by the researchers is that “Parents of children with obesity may experience weight stigma by association, which could have direct consequences for the parents, the children, and the parent-child relationship.” And, no matter how much they themselves weigh, parents of obese kids are rated as less effective. According to the authors of the paper,

There was also an effect of weight stigma wherein parents with obesity were also rated as less effective and helpful than parents without obesity.

Who is doing all this evaluating, and based on what standards?

It comes as no surprise to learn that a lot depends on who performs the evaluations. People who believe that parents are strictly and solely to blame for a child’s obesity do not care if those parents are themselves bulky or slender. The amount of censure is the same. And apparently, when either the young folks or their parents are obese, critics really don’t care how brilliant or talented the obese children in question may be. There is plenty of disapproval to go around.

One unfortunate result is that parents who are blamed and shamed “may internalize the negative parenting evaluations and subject themselves to further self-blame…,” which of course is exactly what their critics hope they will do. Even when parents exert themselves to make sure their methods “align with professional pediatric recommendations,” if their kids are overweight, those parents are still disrespected. The authors write,

One study found that parents who were stigmatized for their own weight reported greater use of restrictive feeding practices…

And yet, other research shows that when moms get strict about feeding, their kids are likely to eat more, not less. In effect, when an obese mama is picked on by someone who likes to stigmatize others, her kids will be even less carefully fed, and probably gain weight.

Another study dug deep and learned that when a girl is called “too fat” by a relative, her odds of being obese 10 years later increase by 62%. So maybe everyone should just pause and consider the many virtues of silence.

Several strengths

Characterized by its authors as possessing several strengths, this study is described as “the first randomized experiment to test weight stigma by association in a parent-child dyad using a large community sample.” Elaborate randomization standards are said to balance all potential variables and confounds across groups. It also involved large numbers of participants.

The authors note that their experimental stimuli “represented positive parenting practices” and
“used the same vignette of the parent-child dyad in all experimental conditions, which was crafted using the AAP parenting recommendations.” Summing up, they say,

Overall, the present randomized experimental study provides causal (rather than merely associative) evidence that weight stigma by association indeed occurs… Though a nascent area of research, weight stigma by association may have potential implications for parenting and effective pediatric obesity care.

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “Weight Stigma by Association Among Parents of Children with Obesity: A Randomized Trial,” ScienceDirect.com, 2022
Image by Tama66/Pixabay

Prepare for the Worst, Part 3

The posts in this sequence explore some of the dark corners of obesity-related attitudes, because parents of children who seem to be headed in that direction might benefit from awareness about the future possibilities. The intention here is not to frighten anyone into locking the potentially obese child into a closet where a few hundred calories per day can be passed through a slit in the door.

However, evidence exists in every corner and on every level of society that the life of a morbidly obese individual is not ideal. Of course, no parent is advised to make a child’s existence miserable in order to avoid obesity. On the other hand, no parent is advised to ignore a potential situation in the hope that it will just go away.

It has long been accepted that to attach “phobia” to a word does not exactly connote fear of the thing. “Homophobia,” for instance, is understood to signify an emotion closer to hatred, but it sounds more acceptable in polite society.

In a nightclub

This sentence in a Psychology Today article was written by Seth Meyers, Psy.D., about a live standup comedy performance where an obese comedian told a stupid joke that would not have been funny, or even interesting, no matter who might have said it. About the audience, Dr. Meyers observed,

They laughed because they hate fat people, and worse, because they believe fat people deserve such spite.

But then, the mental health professional pulled a switcheroo and went on to explain how that was not true at all, and actually, a totally different dynamic was in play. Here is what really happens when haters display their obnoxious behavior:

They’re taking a mental break — almost like releasing a valve with too much pressure — from judging themselves.

In this situation, the performer on stage has volunteered for a role that should have become obsolete centuries ago, and it’s not a court jester. In the olden days, anyone who mattered was forced to live in or near the royal palace, where the monarch could keep an eye on them, and also to make sure that the ruler could be seen to administer justice. But if the crown prince misbehaved, his sacred person could not be violated, so there was a staff member called the whipping boy, who would be punished instead, in the hope that the prince would feel bad and learn how to behave properly.

In modern times

So, what a professionally obese person does is fill the role of whipping boy, absorbing the scorn that members of the general public (in this case, audience members) secretly feel they themselves actually deserve. And at least the stage professional volunteered for the job. But the lady next to you in the airplane didn’t ask to be your whipping boy. She gets the job anyway, as you spend on her that disgust you actually feel for your own 30 extra pounds.

Meyers observes that “there appears to be limitless self-judgment out there in the universe,” which is reflected in the amount of judgment that the ordinary citizen is prepared to dish out, especially on obese people, who are pathetically easy targets. The random observer in the grocery store aisle will not be equipped with enough knowledge to judge you for eating your own hair, but will certainly be able to guess that you eat too many doughnuts.

And, parents: The world is full of sad, mad, self-hating people who can’t wait to judge, dislike, and embarrass your child, in the unconscious and very mistaken belief that pouring out scorn on somebody else will make them feel better, and heal their pain-filled lives.

Here is another thing: While helping our own child to grow up undamaged, we probably don’t particularly want to damage anybody else along the way, or contribute to the unhappiness of somebody we don’t even know. Also, Dr. Meyers suggests a way to help make the world a kinder, more understanding place by taking the Empathy Test.

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “The Psychology of Why People Dislike or Hate Fat People,” PsychologyToday.com, 05/06/11
Image by FreeFunArt/Pixabay

Prepare for the Worst, Part 2

At times, a potential difficulty does not look or sound like much of a threat, especially if no obstacle in that particular genre has been encountered or faced down before. But if and when a poisonous issue strikes, it can take over the entire universe for a while, and impede progress in sneaky and frankly ugly ways. In the sometimes precarious equilibrium of the family, this type of problem is never welcome; and to put up with it for even one day can feel far too long.

Here is the situation. Your daughter or son is overweight, or appears to be leaning in that direction. If and when this kid’s condition starts inspiring you to listen to a podcast about childhood obesity, or to schedule the yearly physical a couple of months early, you are in a good position to stock up on information. What can you do or say to meet the possibility of resistance from some unexpected quarter, and to minimize any threat to your child’s physical and psychological well-being?

Well, plenty, actually. This is why parents follow Childhood Obesity News, use resources like Brainweighve, and harvest random factoids that might come in handy someday. They (you, we) are to be congratulated for that diligence. The family ship makes a course correction and adjusts the sails, the mental, emotional, and physical parameters, to accommodate the new reality.

But — with a project like this, it often turns out that not all possible variables can be accounted for or addressed. For instance, in a clan situation, who wants to believe that some relative is out there feeling the urge to negate the efforts you make toward preventing your child from joining the ranks of a disrespected and ridiculed part of the general population?

Who and why?

The misguided individual might be an older relation who struggles with weight issues and who, consciously or not, follows the “misery loves company” philosophy. Maybe that cousin does not want to be the only obese person in the family circle, and he might even try to undermine your efforts to help the young child avoid obesity. Or it could be an aunt who believes that a teenager can be protected from sexual experimentation by a layer of subcutaneous fat.

If divorce is part of the history, there might be an unavoidable step-parent who is a bad influence or a worse example. This person might be simply careless, or actively desirous of causing trouble. Or, it might be a teacher who is all smiles and enlightenment on visiting day, but who believes that teens should be studying instead of dating; who secretly hopes to let them all share the misery she experienced during adolescence. It could be a family friend whose own kid isn’t very popular, and who feels a twisted need to level the playing field.

If your troubled child is in the teen years, it is possible that someone in his or her friend circle is a real nutcase who gets their kicks from manipulating people and situations in non-obvious ways and for unwholesome reasons.

The bottom line

The ground-level fact of the matter is, not all contingencies can be accounted for or handled.
Like it or not, plenty of folks harbor hostile feelings toward selected groups of their fellow humans. A disturbed individual may simply hate overweight people, or may feel even more animosity toward overweight people with caring parents.

There is no magic advice-wand to wave that can get rid of a lousy influence. For the parent of a growing child, one of the most frustrating problems is the inability to protect that kid from sabotage by a poisonous individual.

Somebody out there with a bad attitude might be hurting your child. If this is the case, maybe you can do something about it; maybe you can’t. But there is a catch. To interfere, or even acknowledge that a conflict exists, might only worsen the situation. For the target, the reason is largely irrelevant. What matters is the damage done.

Still, awareness is half the battle. If your child is dealing with obesity, either now or potentially, parental ignorance will not help. But — even the most healthily transparent child might be unwilling or unready to share some things, and there is nothing wrong with that.

To play detective might serve no purpose. The troublemaker is not interested in improving their character. Some folks are willing and even eager to hurt others for hundreds of misguided reasons, and sometimes they don’t even realize it themselves. It may even be that nothing can be done about this individual. We may have to face the fact that an ongoing situation can’t be avoided.

This message is not just for the custodial parent of a sensitive child, or one who has enough problems already. No, it is for any nearby grownup who might face the pain of knowing that a perfectly nice child is being attacked by some demons right now, or in all likelihood will soon be a target. While you may not be able to stop the pain, there is probably something good you can do.

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Image by Sunriseforever/Pixabay

Prepare for the Worst

It may seem harsh, but a very effective way to develop awareness is to get a taste of some of the things that unfeeling strangers will be saying about your beloved children a few years from now if you don’t get out ahead of this potential problem. It’s a shameless scare tactic, an effort to shock any mom or dad into planning ahead, and vowing to never let their children feel the pain of being ridiculed and ostracized.

The object here is to provide motivation for parents who are not yet dealing with childhood obesity; to solidify their determination that the family will never need to deal with it:

This is how fat-shaming works: It is visible and invisible, public and private, hidden and everywhere at the same time… — Michael Hobbes

To quote what people have said and done is one way to predict what they intend to do. These examples represent how people might be treating your beloved child someday. Probably no one deliberately decides to have a child who will be disrespected or ridiculed because of their appearance. The very fact that we might envision such a fate, and dread it, could make us hate ourselves for being so prejudiced, or for even thinking of such a thing.

But let’s not lose the thread. These glimpses into a potential future are for the benefit of brand-new parents, or for couples still at the stage where parenthood is not yet even a special gleam in the eye:

I struggled with anorexia for years… My girlfriend at the time used to get so mad at me, because she assumed my need to lose weight and be “thin” extended to her. She was perfect and stunningly beautiful, and her fat was never a problem for me. My “fat” was. Because I had a mental illness that almost cost me my life… — crimsoncat21

Obesity prevention is a subject that future moms and dads should probably consider, sooner rather than later, especially if the tendency to be overweight runs in the family. Such a possibility needs to be acknowledged, brought up and discussed, to (hopefully) discourage unnecessary conflict later on. If either parent comes from a heritage where people tend to be overweight, to prepare for that eventuality cannot be wrong.

Could anyone be blamed for making an emotional plea to future parents? Something like, “People may be very disrespectful of your unborn child, someday. They may call your child names and hurt her or him with a thousand small, everyday hostilities. Please make it a priority to not let your child grow up fat.”

To be honest, thin people dealing with fat-phobia is just thin people trying not to look like me. NOT looking like me is worth everything they hate doing but force themselves to suffer through and everything they love but deprive themselves of. As though looking like me is the worst thing they could possibly imagine… — airagorncharda

Is it possible to ever say enough about fat-shaming? Apparently not, because the culture provides a boundless array of examples from which to choose. For the benefit of any reader who wishes to make an in-depth study of this discouraging phenomenon, we gather relevant quotations, useful to any parent or medical professional who has not yet developed a comprehensive mental grasp of the pervasive hate aimed at overweight people in our society:

It’s like the adults are giving the kids permission to view fatness as wrong and something that you need to change… In an effort to make students aware, the campaign had made one girl’s problem far worse… — Lindo Bacon

Journalist Bethany Brookshire interviewed writer, speaker and scientist Lindo Bacon about visiting a school to speak during National Childhood Obesity Month, and how a very large girl student cried because during that period, she came in for even more than the usual share of bullying.

We hope to capture the ear of parents who are not yet dealing with childhood obesity, with the object of motivating them to avoid the issue at all costs. Before that cute, cuddly baby even walks, is the appropriate time to start thinking about this issue and about how to head it off at the pass. Awareness is a wonderful way to begin — awareness of how much you really do not want to see your child or children become victims of fat-phobia.

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “Everything You Know About Obesity is Wrong,” HuffingtonPost.com, 09/19/18
Source: “crimsoncat21,” Tumblr, undated
Source: “Weight shaming is literally sickening,” ScienceNewsForStudents.org, 09/30/21
Image by Ari_Dit/Pixabay

Physicians, Heal Thyselves

A lengthy paper published five years ago discusses fatphobia from many angles, beginning with its progenitor and birthplace, which the authors identify as “diet culture.” In their view, fatphobia is a form of systemic oppression, known by its tendency to condemn the extra-large body as unaesthetic, unattractive, shameful, and even pathological.

The diet culture enthusiasts might even be regarded as cruel liars, who continue to insist that “health, happiness and moral virtue” can only exist in a slender body, and who aim to embarrass, shame, and even demonize their fellow humans by insisting on an ideal vision of beauty that can realistically be attained by only a lucky few.

For some reason unfathomable to many others, these harsh masters reserve their most severe criticism for women who have the nerve to violate the arbitrary rules of bodily perfection. Meanwhile, men do not come in for even a fraction of the condemnation heaped on their sisters, mothers, daughters and wives.

Now, here comes the cringe part…

Fingers are pointed where?

Authors Camille Cottais, Jeanne Pavard, and Marion Sanchez make the following observation:

Medical fatphobia is particularly widespread, discouraging or even preventing fat people from accessing health care.

The illustration on this page represents a quotation from an obese young man who said the worst thing that had happened to him in the past year was when his old physician retired and he suffered great dread about starting over with a new one.

Many doctors have been criticized for participating in the spread of the diet culture, about which these authors refer us to the work of “anti-diet dietician” Christy Harrison. She characterizes diet culture as a “belief system.” This means in practical terms that the active imagination can spin off into reflection on certain antiquated religious practices which still persist in some corners of the world. On holy days of atonement, believers demonstrate regret for their sins by flogging themselves or dragging heavy wooden crosses through the streets.

In the diet culture, we exhibit our faith by jogging along the boulevards or exercising in gyms with big windows at street level. In other words, we feel a need not only to obey the admonitions of proper behavior for the faith, but a compulsion to be seen doing that. And like religions (Methodist, Catholic, Lutheran, etc.), the diet culture has subdivisions: ketogenic, paleo, intermittent fasting, and so forth:

Examples of diet culture include labelling food as good or bad, promoting various kinds of restrictive diets, praising weight loss or eating, not allowing oneself to eat more than a certain number of calories, feeling guilty for eating “too much,” or exercising to punish oneself or to compensate for eating.

Various types of food are assigned moral values, just like the different degrees of respect shown to the housewife who scrubs the floor on her knees after the rest of the family are asleep, and another sort of woman, also up after midnight, who hangs out near the saloon. Some foods are demonized for containing too many calories, or the wrong kind. Meanwhile, a fresh fruit or vegetable is privileged to wear a halo — at least until a cyclosporiasis outbreak comes along and ruins everything.

We all live in this diet culture, existing in a constant state of awareness that even if we have — so far — managed to avoid being labeled fat, that horrid condition could very possibly be our fate next year. From then until forever, we will be punished by having our food choices condemned by the establishment, and possibly also by developing anorexia nervosa, binge-eating disorder, or worse.

And yet, the medical professionals who hope to prevent or reverse obesity in children cannot possibly all be repressive tyrants who anticipate punishing people with too many numerals in their waistlines. They did not make the time investment or endure the workload and expense of medical education only to acquire the privilege of looking down with scorn on overweight people.

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “Fatphobia: a pervasive and socially accepted discrimination,” GrowThinkTank.org, 07/19/21
Images by lapinvert and geralt/Pixabay

FAQs and Media Requests: Click here…

Profiles: Kids Struggling with Weight

Profiles: Kids Struggling with Obesity top bottom

The Book

OVERWEIGHT: What Kids Say explores the obesity problem from the often-overlooked perspective of children struggling with being overweight.

About Dr. Robert A. Pretlow

Dr. Robert A. Pretlow is a pediatrician and childhood obesity specialist. He has been researching and spreading awareness on the childhood obesity epidemic in the US for more than a decade.
You can contact Dr. Pretlow at:

Presentations

Dr. Pretlow’s invited presentation at the American Society of Animal Science 2020 Conference
What’s Causing Obesity in Companion Animals and What Can We Do About It

Dr. Pretlow’s invited presentation at the World Obesity Federation 2019 Conference:
Food/Eating Addiction and the Displacement Mechanism

Dr. Pretlow’s Multi-Center Clinical Trial Kick-off Speech 2018:
Obesity: Tackling the Root Cause

Dr. Pretlow’s 2017 Workshop on
Treatment of Obesity Using the Addiction Model

Dr. Pretlow’s invited presentation for
TEC and UNC 2016

Dr. Pretlow’s invited presentation at the 2015 Obesity Summit in London, UK.

Dr. Pretlow’s invited keynote at the 2014 European Childhood Obesity Group Congress in Salzburg, Austria.

Dr. Pretlow’s presentation at the 2013 European Congress on Obesity in Liverpool, UK.

Dr. Pretlow’s presentation at the 2011 International Conference on Childhood Obesity in Lisbon, Portugal.

Dr. Pretlow’s presentation at the 2010 Uniting Against Childhood Obesity Conference in Houston, TX.

Food & Health Resources