Uppers to the Rescue?

First of all, it hardly seems possible that two such dissimilar conditions would both be alleviated by the same category of pharmaceutical. An article from the journal Eating Behaviors addressed…

[…] the existing evidence on stimulant medication in the management of patients with bulimia nervosa (BN) or anorexia nervosa (AN) with or without comorbid attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).

Medical journalists looked at 13 pertinent articles concerning mainly patients suffering from bulimia nervosa. All the patients in these studies were treated with various stimulant drugs, and many experienced improvement in their eating disorder symptoms.

At the same time, however, numerous adverse effects tended to occur. These included…

[…] weight loss, decreased appetite, tachycardia, dry mouth, fatigue, insomnia, restlessness, nausea, bruxism, headache, palpitations, blood pressure changes, irritability, anxiety, depressed mood, and diaphoresis…

The use of stimulants was seen to be effective (up to a point) in many cases, but unpredictable and often unacceptable because of all the side issues. This lack of satisfaction led to a recommendation to screen such patients for attention deficit hyperactivity disorder.

The strange part is, other evidence shows that stimulant drugs can be quite surprisingly successful in alleviating ADHD. A connection, albeit far from clear, has been acknowledged.

What a paradox

A short time ago, we looked at the newly explored connection between ADHD and disordered eating. Namely, both conditions are amenable to improvement through the use of stimulant drugs (of which Ritalin and Adderall are two examples).

It seems weird how “uppers” can enable hyper kids to mellow out — but that capacity to develop a bit of calmness has helped a lot of them fit into society successfully enough to avoid juvenile hall. As it turns out, in many cases the same pharmaceuticals can help a different constituency of kids to avoid fat camp.

There is more to be said about both of those possibilities. One is to explore a universal truth. The desire to escape blame (or even its milder cousin, responsibility) is perfectly human. However, although parents tend to find inevitable reasons to explain why things happen to their children, that perfectly natural response is not the preferred scenario.

To look for an “out” is a bad habit that benefits no one, and is in fact a bit too close to pulling the wool over one’s own eyes. For instance, not all chubby kids inevitably settle into lifelong obesity — but their parents might too readily accept that possibility. A parent might say, “Oh don’t worry, I was a fat child, but then we got a pool and started to swim, and I turned out okay.”

Now the other case: A child who seems to experience attention deficit disorder or hyperactivity (also successfully addressed by those same drugs). A parent may tend to say, “Oh don’t worry, when I was a kid I had ants in my pants, could never sit still, and look at me, I turned out fine.” Then again, maybe not.

One way a parent can fail a child is by allotting too much credit and permission to genealogy. Maybe great grandpa Charles was a circus fat man, but none of his descendants need to follow in those ponderous footsteps. The physical traits of one’s ancestors make a big difference, sure, but rarely is a sentence of lifelong obesity carved in stone.

Whatever seems to be “wrong” with a child, please don’t take anything for granted. Maybe he or she does need meds of some kind. Or maybe the family needs an introduction to BrainWeighve.

Moms and dads, grandmas and grandpas, don’t fall for the “easy out.” Take a clear-eyed look at where your ideas come from, because maybe it’s time to update. If a child is hooked on eating to the point where it looks like an addiction, please get a clue and communicate clearly with both your child and the other parent and your own inner self.

This stuff is too important to lie to ourselves about. Slide on over to this other Dr. Pretlow website, and check out this post about self-deception.

Find such wisdom as a reminder from the theoretical physicist Richard Feynman, one of the smartest humans who ever lived. He said, “You must not fool yourself and you are the easiest person to fool.” As a parent, please don’t let your kids suffer from your inability to face up to the mistakes and omissions buried in your own past.

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “Stimulant medications in the management of bulimia nervosa and anorexia nervosa in patients with and without comorbid attention deficit hyperactivity disorder: A systematic review,” ScienceDirect.com, August 2024
Image by qimono/Pixabay

Eating Disorders and ADHD: The Missing Link

At first glance, it probably would not occur to a layperson to suspect that, in children, Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) would have any connection with eating disorders. And yet, it appears that a relationship has always existed, although recognition of that fact is characterized as “relatively new.” Here are some words about Harvard Medical School discoveries:

Research has demonstrated that individuals with ADHD have a greater risk for developing binge eating disorder or bulimia nervosa than their peers without ADHD… Girls with ADHD were almost four times more likely to have an eating disorder than those without ADHD. Another empirical study found that 11 percent of women with ADHD, compared to 1 percent of women without, reported a history of bulimia nervosa.

Attention deficit implies poor impulse control; so does binge eating (BED). ADHD can make a person feel inadequate and unable to cope with life. Consequently, in an effort to find relief from that situation, plenty of folks see food as the answer. Humans are sadly prone to paradoxes, or psychological wrinkles of which they are unconscious. One of those is the unfortunate belief that eating is a way to exert control over one’s own life, even when it leads to a bad place.

Science backs up the connection:

Both people with BED and people with ADHD have trouble heeding their internal cues of satiety and hunger… A hyperfocus on food may be appealing to individuals with ADHD, since it simplifies their thinking about the subject.

An individual’s development into responsible adulthood requires the ability to devote a boatload of focused attention that nevertheless must be dispersed among an overwhelming number of diverse areas. To name just a few — financial responsibility; accountability when put in charge of other people’s needs; the expectation of showing up for work on time; the ongoing necessity to keep track of objects (like keys and wallets) that must not be lost; the expectation that one can and will respond appropriately to either friendly advances or hostile approaches; the list just goes on and on.

The upside?

Still, a person can usually exert control over what does or does not go into their mouth. Whether someone decides to eat more than is wise, or less than is sane, they still get to be the boss of that department. This can provide a great deal of relief from the stress of paying attention to numerous conflicting demands that not only need to be met, but must be attended to at appropriate times and with the required amount of serious intent.

During a hard day of allotting precious attention to all those extraneous requirements, dominance over the kingdom of the self can be exerted by devouring a large pizza and a quart of ice cream; or maybe by fasting like a medieval saint.

As author Roberto Olivardia, Ph.D., points out, this rats’ nest of avoidance and engulfment can metamorphose into a problem that requires a whole team of medical professionals to sort out. It may even lead to treatment with stimulant drugs. Helpful as that approach sometimes may be, it can also lead to the same hell, only through a different gate.

When it comes to children whose attention capacity is all over the map, a stimulant drug can often help them. Common sense would say, “Wait a minute, wouldn’t that just turn the child into a little speed freak with even less ability to focus her mind enough to concentrate on anything for more than a few seconds at a time?” But common sense would be mistaken.

Ritalin, Adderall, and other prescription stimulants “act primarily on the brain’s reward and wakefulness centers, rather than on its attention circuitry,” according to such medical experts as Benjamin Kay, M.D., Ph.D., and Nico U. Dosenbach, M.D., Ph.D. Their work has shown that…

[…] stimulant medications produced patterns of brain activity that mimicked the effect of good sleep, negating the effects of sleep deprivation on brain activity.

(To be continued…)

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “Stimulant ADHD medications work differently than thought,” WASHU.edu, 12/24/25
Image by EME/Pixabay

One Organization, One Person, Working It Out

For many years, Oprah was assumed to be the literal embodiment of the Weight Watchers credo of self-reliance that included willpower, calorie-counting, and exercise. For people who clung to it faithfully and still failed to lose weight, this mindset left them no choice but to feel inadequate, guilty, and just generally bad about themselves.

At the end of 2023, the news came that jolted Earth from its axis. Oprah was taking The Drugs. One way or another, many people felt betrayed, and understandably so. They had bought into the official do-it-yourself line, and felt they had been used somehow.

Some were mad at Oprah for holding a leadership position for almost a decade. Others were angry about her resignation. It was a classic “damned if you do and damned if you don’t” scenario, and being trapped as the villain in that situation could force a person into stress-related eating in a minute.

Journalist Vanessa Romo noted that Oprah promised to be “a vocal advocate in advancing this conversation” — an equivocal statement if ever there was one. Maybe, at that moment, certainty about exactly what to emphasize did not exist in her own mind. More likely, it was a nagging feeling that she had not quite worked out the most honest and effective way to say it.

The result was one of the least eloquent quotations ever credited to Ms. Winfrey:

Real integrity is doing the right thing, knowing that nobody’s going to know whether you did it or not.

Public opinion, AKA “the court of”

Drugs, both legal and illegal, and whatever their intended purpose, are one area of life where people’s deeply held convictions tend to polarize, politicize, stigmatize, and emotionalize. As always, on such a hot topic, public opinion was all over the map, on a runaway bus driven by strong impulses, including opposite feelings within the same person. Oprah’s fanbase, taken as a single entity, was ambivalent (to say the least) about her embrace of the GLP-1 school of healing.

The strain exerted upon any prominent figure whose every word is scrutinized without mercy must be enormous. If Oprah ended her associations with Weight Watchers, that meant somebody had to be wrong, and one trait of “the public” is that it loves to form an opinion based on very slim evidence. But after nearly a decade as a board member, end it she did.

Then, another bomb dropped. As reported by Vanessa Romo,

[…] WeightWatchers unveiled the rollout of WeightWatchers Clinic, which gives members access to doctors who can prescribe weight loss medications… The services were made possible after WW’s acquisition of a telehealth company called Sequence last spring.

Weight Watchers CEO Sima Sistani told the press that the organization’s path had never worked for some aspiring weight-losers, because they were up against “a chronic relapsing condition, with biology and genetics and environmental underpinnings.” Consequently, it was determined that the time had come “to reintroduce ourselves […] to acknowledge the part that we had in the past.”

Parting ways

Nobody wanted to create a perception that something fishy was going on, or that enmity existed between the giant W’s, namely Winfrey and Weight Watchers — but there must be no appearance of inappropriate friendship, either.

The separation happened partly because Oprah was planning a significant TV special about prescription weight-loss meds. Weight Watchers had entered the pharmaceutical business by purchasing a telehealth company and would receive financial benefit from GLP-1 sales. For that and other reasons, it was no longer appropriate for her to be the public face of Weight Watchers; she needed to detach.

Just to make matters even more transparent, Oprah announced that she would donate her share of Weight Watchers income to charity, and the nine remaining members of the board stood behind her because the generous gesture would sweep away suspicions of a conflict of interest.

It took the public a while to digest that much change, but there was more to come. In March, Oprah told TV host Jimmy Kimmel and his audience and the rest of the world that she would now be able to “talk about whatever I want.”

Which, of course, she knew would not stem any of the criticism from the critically-inclined. But it would confirm her own sense of integrity and upright behavior, which, after all, is the most important thing.

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “After nearly a decade, Oprah Winfrey is set to depart the board of WeightWatchers,” Wamu.org, 03/01/24
Source: “Oprah Winfrey resigned from WeightWatchers board to ‘talk about whatever I want’ in new special”, FoxBusiness.com, 03/17/24
Image by Lawrence Jackson/Public Domain

The World and Oprah’s World

If we talk about ice skaters, we have to mention Sonja Henie, and if we talk about science fiction writers, we have to mention Harlan Ellison. And people who have occupied the “public figure” stage? Oprah Winfrey, no contest. As one of the most recognizable and respected celebrities on the planet, this woman’s every word and action have been the subject of close scrutiny for decades, especially since everyone who does not happen to be Oprah seems to feel obligated to chime in with an opinion about every breath she draws.

In the USA and even on the world stage, many favorite topics of conversation have been Oprah-centric: her accomplishments, her acting, her generosity, her spirit, her knack for spotting talent, and of course, always and forever, her relationship with her body; specifically its size and weight.

Just when it seemed impossible that fate could provide the opportunity to explore yet another facet of Oprah, it happened. The world had not seen such a scandal since a king of England resigned his position in order to marry a divorced commoner.

The upset

In 2023, the star stated publicly that, for some time after hearing about the new weight-loss medications, she had continued to feel that personal willpower was the only legitimate way to pursue weight loss. But then as the months slid by, her thinking evolved.

In the autumn of that year, the OprahDaily.com website mentioned some of its reasons for existing. One was to banish the idea that obesity can and should only be cured by personal willpower. Using medicine to treat obesity is just as legitimate as using antibiotics to treat infection, and that principle needed to be respectfully brought into the house and given a seat. The text plainly said that the site’s intention was…

To discuss the safety and efficacy of the new weight loss drugs, such as Ozempic, Wegovy, and Mounjaro.

Meanwhile, Oprah had served on the Weight Watchers board of directors for nearly a decade, and a difference of opinion had developed. The people who had been tracking that situation and shaking their heads were proven correct when, at the end of February 2024, Oprah resigned from the board.

Much of the reporting served only to confuse the issue. Oprah’s personal decision, made some months before, to start taking a weight-loss drug was regarded by a segment of the public, including some of her most loyal fans, as a betrayal. It was as if Oprah had been caught stepping out on her long-time gentleman friend.

Some fans were angry, others were sad. But this judgment was complicated by the fact that Weight Watchers had already bought a telehealth platform whose services included “access to healthcare providers who can prescribe weight-loss drugs including Ozempic.”

That development left many Weight Watchers members confused about where to aim their displeasure — at the organization, or Oprah, or both, or neither? Some felt betrayed, without knowing exactly why, or how to react, or which port to seek in this storm. Some critics seemed to base their disapproval on very shaky ground, almost as if they believed as a general principle that no one should ever be allowed to change their mind, even if evidence, experience, and logic might point toward making a behavioral adjustment.

New year, new problems

Meanwhile, as 2025 rolled in, Oprah stated publicly that the existence of medically approved prescription drugs for weight loss felt “like redemption… not something to hide behind and once again be ridiculed for.” The fact that she owned a lot of Weight Watchers stock added to the dismay.

Did that make her a loyal company woman, or a traitor? Did this aspect of her business life define her as an oppressive fat-shamer who profited from the pain of ordinary members, or what?

Plenty of former supporters were unhappy with their fallen hero, even if they couldn’t put their finger on exactly why. It is a human characteristic to admire someone who takes a rigid stand, no matter how harmful that position might be. At the same time, another ineradicable human trait is to scold someone mercilessly for “flip-flopping,” as if changing one’s mind is the worst sin ever.

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Image by Pat Hartman

The Family That Haunts Together, Flaunts Together

“Mommy, what does flaunt mean?”

“It means to show off, dear. We show off our scary costumes. This year we are ghosts!”

“But it isn’t nice to brag. Remember, you said!”

“Okay then. ‘The family that haunts together, eats croissants together.’ How about that for our slogan?”

“Daddy, now Mommy is trying to brag. Make her stop! Besides, nobody in our neighborhood gives away croissants.”

But Daddy is never at a loss. “You’re right. Hey, I’ve got it. The family that spooks together, pukes together.”

Of course, this is an immediate hit. Except for one thing. After the child’s laughing fit is over, insatiable curiosity remains. “But why do we puke?”

“From eating all the yucky candy the neighbors are giving us instead of croissants, of course.”

Hey, this is supposed to be fun, right?

If childhood obesity were a person, and we bravely asked, “Hey, Childhood Obesity, what is your favorite holiday?,” it’s a pretty good bet that the answer would be, “What are you, crazy? Halloween, of course! No contest!” Because it is all about gobs of sugar in every conceivable shape and form, which (and this is not an inconsequential detail) comes for free.

Adjacent activities

Year after year, Halloween provides a raucous, colorful, and all-welcoming kickoff to the winter holiday season, beginning with supermarkets stocking their shelves with witch and ghost candy before the kids are even back in school. Okay, slight exaggeration. But not by much.

One thing that children can do in the midst of the current year’s activities is to make notes about cool stuff they see other people doing. This will involve such actions as writing down an idea so coherently that it will be understood after 11 months have passed, and storing the information in such a way that it will be easily findable when the time comes. Those are good, useful skills for anyone to develop.

Immediately after the holiday, organize a family trip to a store that wants to move a whole lot of scary merchandise for cheap. Be sure to make it clear, ahead of time, that candy is not on the menu. You are looking for bargain-priced costumes, masks, and items of decor that can be carefully packed up and labeled for next year. And keep an eye out for a fancy, high-quality pumpkin carving kit on sale that could transform next year’s holiday into a fabulous art festival.

Less candy, more fun

And don’t just mull over ideas about what the family could do for next year’s October-ending holiday. Think big! You and your kids could start laying the groundwork to be involved with plans for the school or the community center or the homeless shelter, and create more fun for everybody within miles.

Here is another pre-Halloween warm-up project: Recruit your child or children into composing a super-healthful menu for the evening meal, one that will fulfill so many of the body’s cravings for quality that it won’t even be interested in candy.

Okay, maybe that is too ambitious a goal. But try letting the young folks design the supper and prepare it, or at least help. They are more likely to actually eat something they chose and then cooked themselves, and the end result just might be less resistance to putting the candy away for doling out in an orderly fashion later.

Overall, what a lot of parents would like to do is minimize the caloric intake and maximize the fun. Yes, it’s too late this year to organize something like a costume parade at a retirement community, but make a note for next year, maybe on September’s last day, to get busy arranging some Halloween activities that don’t involve eating — and then, when the time comes, just be sure to follow through!

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Image by LensPulse/Pixabay

Painful and Harsh Truths

These words are here to pick up some thoughts dropped a few days ago as “Harsh and Painful Truths,” of the kind that keep coming back to haunt us.

Some realities need to be accepted. One of them is: People resent paying for other people’s mistakes. The average American is generally okay with the idea that tax dollars will help a person who was pushed onto the subway tracks and suffered a leg amputation.

But if the issue is someone who has spent a lifetime becoming corpulent, when that misfortune could have been prevented, it’s a different matter. The idea of contributing to the kitty for a morbidly obese person’s medical expenses just might be considered objectionable.

In many people’s minds obesity is, always and only, a preventable situation. They feel no empathy for anyone who bought a packet of white powder and contracted a major addiction, on the grounds that the person should have known better. Viewed from the perspective of that same mindset, obesity is an almost identical situation. Whether objectively justifiable or not, it is the way a large number of people feel.

Meanwhile, someone with a generous and forgiving nature might hope to convince the hard-hearted to be less critical, and to spare the feelings of addicts who are now trying to change. Another response would be to use that energy in a different way, like by convincing people to not become addicts in the first place. Similarly, those who care about the obesity issue, and who don’t want to see obese people getting their feelings hurt, might choose to support issues connected with the prevention of that condition.

A heavy work

We will not go into the whole text here, but it could be useful to take a peek at a five-author article from Journal of Managed Care & Specialty Pharmacy, with the cumbersome but usefully descriptive title, “Costs of obesity, obesity-related complications, and weight loss in the United States: A systematic literature review.”

The work’s abstract quite usefully states that last year, around 100 million American grownups were obese. (The point we are aiming at is one that should be obvious from the start. Surely, their hundreds of thousands of parents did not mean for that to happen. Those moms and dads never intended for their beloved offspring to become PwO, or People with Obesity!)

Of those hundred million obese American adults, 75% or three-quarters of them also suffer from complications related to that obese condition. Here is a direct quotation pertaining to their condition:

“Related medical spending exceeds $261 billion.”

Subsequent to that thought, we are told that the objective of this study was to summarize the estimates of the direct medical costs incurred by those PwO…

[…] by obesity severity and presence of obesity-related complications and to characterize the impact of weight loss on direct medical cost savings.

The methodology is then explained, and it translates to an understanding that this task involved a lot of complicated work. Before even starting, the individuals concerned were divided into groups (class I, II, or III) according to the severity of their obesity. Anyway, almost 10,000 related records were consulted, and the researchers identified 6.0 of them, or 32 studies, as being useful for their purposes.

Here was some unwelcome news. Obesity-related complications (such as hypertension and type 2 diabetes) do not wind up costing just a little bit more than plain old obesity, but a lot more. And yet, a relatively simple (for some individuals) weight loss of only 5% over a year could lead to “substantial savings.” Weight-loss medications were found to help, too.

Obviously, a lot more facts and figures were involved in deducing numerous conclusions, and not surprisingly,

[L]ongitudinal studies considering a wider range and overlap of obesity-related complications are needed to help document and quantify the current direct cost burden of obesity.

What is the point here? Glad you asked. Most people who read this blog have children, and hold many aspirations for those young lives. We hope to see our kids grow up to be champion athletes, or career-qualified musicians, or dedicated teachers, or farmers who care as much about preserving the land as they do about making profits.

This sort of future-gazing could go on and on, but there is a point. Not one of us, not a single parent among us, is sitting here thinking, “Gee, I hope my kid grows up to be a PwO — especially one with extra-disabling and super-costly complications!”

This suggestion is for anyone whose kids might be headed in an overweight direction: Please consider getting acquainted with a system called BrainWeighve, which could make an enormous difference in the lives of not only our own kids, but also their children — the next generation who are not even here yet.

We have the opportunity to shape and guide the fates of people far into the future. To guarantee that our present-day progeny will not grow up obese could make a difference that reverberates and resonates down through the years. And what have we got to lose by giving it a chance?

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “Costs of obesity, obesity-related complications, and weight loss in the United States: A systematic literature review,” Journal of Managed Care & Specialty Pharmacy, July 2025
Image by jarmoluk/Pixabay

Harsh and Painful Truths

Many of us were brought up to believe that talking about money all the time — “harping” on the subject, as some of our folks might have put it — is in poor taste; a crass and undignified habit. But since when has telling people not to dwell on a topic ever changed what they do in the privacy of their own heads?

Besides, not having money can also be undignified and crass, and it behooves us to give the subject a bit of thought, now and then. Here, in this blog, it is appropriate to think about how much our individual habits and mistakes might penalize society as a whole, causing some members of that society to feel an urge to take revenge on our kids in some way. This is not a good feeling to have, and might even keep some of us awake at night, as well it should.

It fits right in with the “blame and shame” theme

In calculating the economic cost of obesity to society, several factors are considered, of which perhaps the most obvious is direct medical spending. Over the past decade, it has been estimated that an obese adult will rack up almost $2,000 more in yearly medical expenses than a healthy-weight adult, and with severe obesity that excess figure can hit $3,000.

Some factors are harder to pin down or assign precise figures to, but it has been observed that in the workplace, obesity relates to reduced productivity, absenteeism, claims filed for disability, and the depletion of workers’ compensation funds. The three extra workdays per year that an average obese individual misses do not initially sound like much, but they add up. Our source is “Costs of obesity, obesity-related complications, and weight loss in the United States: A systematic literature review.”

A decade past

In 2016, estimated national productivity losses were between $13 billion and (twice that number) $26 billion, depending on which study was consulted. Some researchers found that if they included other factors, like related diseases and premature death amongst workers, the loss could be quoted as more than a trillion dollars annually.

The scholars who write about such matters tend to point out that the price is not always paid by the obese individuals who incur those costs. Sure, the patients often pony up a hefty share, but then so do their employers, and the insurers they work with, along with government programs and the taxpayers who contribute to them. But no matter how you slice it, the bill for a lot of people’s obesity is picked up by the general public.

The bottom line

This is why it is important to remind the parents of children how it all works. We don’t want our kids growing up to be burdens on society. Even if we ourselves do not think of societal responsibility for healthcare as a particularly bad idea, please be assured that plenty of people do feel that way. If we let our kids grow into obese adults, they will always be unpopular with someone, and why on earth would we allow them to slide into such a fate? It seems like we ought to do everything we can to prevent it.

Very few parents would wish for a child to reach adulthood as a shunned and even hated individual. Mothers and fathers who would not have an objectionable picture tattooed onto their child’s face might still unthinkingly participate in facilitating that child’s growth into an obese adult. That is, into a grownup who could one day be scorned, just as sincerely as someone who wears a signed contract with Beelzebub on his or her forehead.

(To be continued…)

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “Costs of obesity, obesity-related complications, and weight loss in the United States: A systematic literature review,” Journal of Managed Care & Specialty Pharmacy, July 2025
Image by geralt/Pixabay

A Useful “Creator Toolkit” From Harvard

The full title of the work is “Unpacking Fatphobia, Weight Discrimination, and Their Deadly Repercussions.” When we see the word “useful,” the question that naturally comes to mind is, “Who can benefit from this information?”

The answer would include any parent, teacher, student, news columnist, speaker at a club or organization function, or really anyone who is interested in helping others understand what is going on with the societal attitude toward overweight and obese Americans. The document itself mentions what might, in this day and age, be the most useful aspect of knowing some things about this touchy subject: “to help content creators spread evidence-based health information on social media.”

In any such context, by the way, it is also useful to mention that the author of the post, article, or speech is offering educational information, which is not to be mistaken for actual medical advice. If needed, that aspect should of course be followed up on by consultation with an appropriate medical professional.

Especially for the family

A parent, for instance, might want to address some particular aspect of obesity, to help their child to understand why there is concern about that child’s own habits and inclinations.

Or — and we hope this never comes up, but it might — a mom or dad might overhear their child mocking some obese person, and find a non-confrontational way to gently help create understanding of the circumstances that could have led to that unfortunate person’s weight problem. This might also present an opportunity to make some points about how their own family can take responsibility for assuring that none of its members will, one day, be the butt of someone else’s humor, meanness, or scorn.

For those who are already convinced and don’t even need to hear any more details or reasons, but are anxious to get right to it, here is the address.

Down to it

The first section emphasizes how weight-based bias is actually a problem that affects everyone. But the main way in which it affects obese people is that it’s worse than wrong; it’s useless — because it does not help anyone become healthier. That’s right, criticism actually confers no health benefits, but actively worsens the health and wellbeing of its targets. Here is the succinct but definitive quotation on that topic:

Experiencing weight discrimination harms people’s physical and mental health, reduces their engagement in healthy activities, like exercising, and ironically increases the likelihood that they will gain weight.

The document goes on to explain what numerous studies have confirmed: that discrimination merely increases people’s stress levels and has an overall tendency to cause a decrease in the quality of their healthcare.

If the health of such an individual is a true concern, critics should be aware that “it is impossible to tell how ‘healthy’ someone is just from looking at them.” We are reminded that if our true wish is to deal only in respectful, supportive dialogue, we should remind our communities to “ask people what terminology they prefer and use their preferred language in conversations.”

Another section of the document contains the astonishing information that, in all but one American state (Michigan), it is actually legal to discriminate against a person based on his or her weight.

And so…

What sorts of actions can a conscientious individual take to improve the situation? Several are suggested. The compilers go on to discuss the topics of blame and shame, a pair of words that will by now be very familiar to readers of Childhood Obesity News. That section delves into quite a bit of detail about the many insidious ways in which harmful attitudes can affect people and relationships.

Additionally, there are all kinds of mental gymnastics and emotional traps involved in how different types of people address these topics. For instance,

Seeing others lose weight may bring up feelings of betrayal in people who see weight loss as a decision to abandon a political fight.

Once a person begins to seriously look into this matter, it becomes apparent that there is much more to it than meets the eye. The authors mention the need to examine and reflect upon “the complexity of how our weight and health are politicized.” It is also useful to examine how an ostensible concern about people’s weight may be inextricably entwined, in one way or another, with the ubiquitous factor known as the profit motive.

But wait, there is more…

Also on offer are some interesting statistics. If the mental health of the population is a concern, we can reflect on the increased risk of mood disorders and anxiety disorders experienced by people who are regarded as overweight. For those who feel targeted by it, weight discrimination can even lead to an earlier death than they would otherwise have experienced.

Reliance on the old but not yet replaced BMI standard can harm large numbers of people by causing them to be misclassified. And here is an interesting statistic:

18 out of the top 25 teen TV shows displayed characters being teased for their weight.

As attentive and sensitive to public opinion as entertainment media producers are known to be, it seems like this would be a relatively easy and potentially rewarding area in which to invest critical energy.

This guide also provides a handy starter list of media resources including documentary films, podcasts, brochures, websites and reports for further self-education, and ideas about how to help our entire society experience a much-needed shift in attitude.

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “Unpacking Fatphobia, Weight Discrimination, and Their Deadly Repercussions,” Harvard.edu
Image: Used under the Pixabay Content License

Medical Professionals and the “Heal Thyselves” Hope

It appears that fatphobia among medical professionals has been disappointingly and rather shockingly widespread, and may still be. A few years back, a research team looked into the terminology most resisted by patients, but also pointed out how difficult it is for medics to please everybody in such a sensitive realm.

The document in question is an exploration of issues and observed behavior that had been looked at before, and have continued to be scrutinized in the recent past, and will probably need an eye kept on them in the future. In “Implicit and Explicit Weight Bias in a National Sample of 4,732 Medical Students,” the authors state,

Although the medical profession attracts people who are highly committed to helping others, those pursuing the profession are still susceptible to societal biases against obese people… Implicit and explicit weight bias is common among 1st year medical students, and varies across student factors.

Also drawing from other previously published materials, the team set out to explore “the magnitude of explicit and implicit weight biases compared to biases against other groups.” First-year students from 49 medical schools participated in a survey designed to get a handle on exactly how much anti-fat sentiment existed among them. For agreement or disagreement, it offered the participants such statements as:

I really don’t like fat people much.

I have a hard time taking fat people seriously.

Fat people tend to be fat pretty much through their own fault.

Some people are fat because they have no will power.

Among many of the respondents, attitudes tended to be judgmental, but a considerable self-referential emotional component was also at work. Apparently the very existence, and especially the close proximity, of overweight humans can trigger existential angst:

Fat people make me feel somewhat uncomfortable.

I feel disgusted with myself when I gain weight.

I worry about myself when I gain weight.

As it turned out,

A majority of students exhibited implicit (74%) and explicit (67%) weight bias. Implicit weight bias scores were comparable to reported bias against racial minorities. Explicit attitudes were more negative toward obese people than toward racial minorities, gays, lesbians, and poor people.

That statement should stop any thinking person in their tracks.

In addition to the study this work is mainly concerned with, the authors cite many previous research papers that also apply to the dilemma. They note the existence of a “growing body of research” that reveals care providers’ “explicit and implicit biases about patients’ stigmatized social characteristics.” Obviously, such attitudes can endanger aspects of patient care, and possibly decrease the likelihood of deriving any benefit from interaction with the medical establishment. The authors say,

It has been observed that race bias in healthcare providers follows a pattern of high implicit bias and low explicit bias, which has been labeled aversive prejudice.

Explicit biases are defined as being intentional and conscious, and are assessed by self-report, in a process where it is hoped that honest responses can be assumed. The majority of the research intention was to capture and focus on the implicit sort of bias, the sort that is automatically activated within the subject’s psyche and occurs unconsciously, although it is to be hoped that participants can eventually recognize it in themselves. This sort of reaction is measured using response-latency tasks like the Implicit Association
Task (IAT), which measures “the strength of association between social categories and attitudes.”

In the medical context, common stereotypes involved in a care provider’s implicit or explicit racial bias have been linked to less-than-optimal behavior in the areas of decision-making; the judgment of communication as satisfactory or otherwise; and of course in the ratings requested from patients about the quality of care. Since some students honestly reported that they liked obese people even less than racial minorities, this did not bode well.

Medical personnel are of course often called upon to treat not only members of other races, but convicted criminals who, while they should be entitled to humane care, probably do not deserve large amounts of approval. Physicians, nurses, and other staff are also compelled to deal with patients in extreme states of disorientation or hostility caused by alcohol or illicit drug use, involving substances whose effect sometimes turns out to be more homicidal than recreational. Medical personnel have to confront the sometimes grotesque results of sexually transmitted diseases and other conditions with which the ordinary citizen is thankfully unfamiliar.

And yet, somehow, for some individuals, taking care of overweight patients can be even worse.

(To be continued…)

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Source: “Implicit and Explicit Weight Bias in a National Sample of 4,732 Medical Students: The Medical Student CHANGES Study,” ResearchGate.net, April 2014
Image by CaringforCare/Pixabay

“The Talk” and Its Repercussions

This blog has been looking at some of the many sources of grievance that can be found in the ever-increasing existence of obesity in the USA — most of which, if the truth is acknowledged, revolve around money. People who don’t have much of it are upset because they are blamed for the fact that they can’t afford excellent nutritious food for themselves and their children. People who have lots of it are indignant because the tax dollars they begrudgingly part with are used by poor people to buy potato chips instead of broccoli.

Some people are unhappy because they can’t afford treatment for the obesity that others feel is “their own darn fault, so why should we pay for their weight-loss drugs and their gym memberships?” Some are embittered because no matter how they run their own household, once the kids are old enough to go to school, many diverse influences will be working on those little minds contrary to their parents’ beliefs and wishes.

A lot of grownups are quite reasonably and justifiably angry about the advertising that is everywhere, from which they cannot protect their children unless they join a community that forswears electricity and other modern conveniences. Many parents feel helpless against the overwhelming force of ubiquitous and relentless advertising.

Tell me something I don’t know, ha ha

Kids don’t want to be told what to do, and the question of what they eat is not one that arises once a year, when they want something outrageous for Christmas; or once in their high school career when a girl wants a scandalously expensive senior prom dress; or only when the kid starts campaigning for the parents to buy him or her a car; or once a month when they want extra cash to go to a movie.

No. What goes into those young mouths is a question that arises every single day, week after week, month after month, year after year. Even the most conscientious adults cannot control what their children eat outside the home. Even the most caring parents have to give up sometimes, or risk blowing the whole relationship right off the map.

Slow your roll, Mom and Dad

Speaking of dangerous territory, family dynamics can be so unhealthy and unproductive that parental warnings actually cause the very result that the parents dread. A teen girl who is hounded by her parents about the possibility of pregnancy just might (consciously or unconsciously) express her opinion of the nagging by going out and — you guessed it — conceiving an unwelcome grandchild.

An adolescent boy who catches too much flack on the subject of unsuitable companions could very possibly react by seeking out those exact undesirables to hang out with, and incur consequences that wind up in a courtroom or in even more dire surroundings.

Even if such extreme outcomes are avoided, the fact still remains that an obese kid will probably become an obese adult, and face very unwelcome reactions from other adults. How useful is it to warn a child that today’s behavior regarding food could easily turn into tomorrow’s life of miserable rejection?

Answer: not very useful at all. In fact, most likely any such prognostications will be, at least, laughed off and at most, resented to an extent that can lead to no good end.

Public opinion and private behavior

It goes without saying that the surest way to become an obese adult is to be an obese child and/or teenager, and obese adults catch a lot of flack. In the world of work, even if “the company” pays for employees’ weight-reduction drugs, that is money subtracted from what the business might otherwise be paying the non-obese employees in the form of various benefits. And of course, the same goes when “the government” (also known as “our tax dollars”) picks up the tab for obesity treatment.

The reaction becomes even more intense when people get news reports bearing such bad news as the fact that two years after learning that someone else will pay for their GLP-1 meds, three out of four — that’s 75% — of those patients quit taking the drugs or refuse to adhere to the entire weight-loss regimen that includes other factors.

Another important aspect of the entire controversy is uncertainty about the long-term effects of weight-loss meds on the children who are increasingly becoming involved with them. This is perhaps the most unfortunate result of the development of oral medications to replace what used to be available only in injectable form. While we might not want children to be involved with needles (and neither do they), pills are a whole different proposition, making it way too easy to glide along into a “new normal” that could turn into a nightmare.

Your responses and feedback are welcome!

Images by NB_art and MoteOo/Pixabay

FAQs and Media Requests: Click here…

Profiles: Kids Struggling with Weight

Profiles: Kids Struggling with Obesity top bottom

The Book

OVERWEIGHT: What Kids Say explores the obesity problem from the often-overlooked perspective of children struggling with being overweight.

About Dr. Robert A. Pretlow

Dr. Robert A. Pretlow is a pediatrician and childhood obesity specialist. He has been researching and spreading awareness on the childhood obesity epidemic in the US for more than a decade.
You can contact Dr. Pretlow at:

Presentations

Dr. Pretlow’s invited presentation at the American Society of Animal Science 2020 Conference
What’s Causing Obesity in Companion Animals and What Can We Do About It

Dr. Pretlow’s invited presentation at the World Obesity Federation 2019 Conference:
Food/Eating Addiction and the Displacement Mechanism

Dr. Pretlow’s Multi-Center Clinical Trial Kick-off Speech 2018:
Obesity: Tackling the Root Cause

Dr. Pretlow’s 2017 Workshop on
Treatment of Obesity Using the Addiction Model

Dr. Pretlow’s invited presentation for
TEC and UNC 2016

Dr. Pretlow’s invited presentation at the 2015 Obesity Summit in London, UK.

Dr. Pretlow’s invited keynote at the 2014 European Childhood Obesity Group Congress in Salzburg, Austria.

Dr. Pretlow’s presentation at the 2013 European Congress on Obesity in Liverpool, UK.

Dr. Pretlow’s presentation at the 2011 International Conference on Childhood Obesity in Lisbon, Portugal.

Dr. Pretlow’s presentation at the 2010 Uniting Against Childhood Obesity Conference in Houston, TX.

Food & Health Resources